Blogs 'have affected my family' - magistrate
A magistrate yesterday told a court that a series of articles about her published on Daphne Caruana Galizia's website amounted to "persistent harassment" which affected her and her children.
Magistrate Consuelo Scerri Herrera was giving evidence in the case instituted by the police against the columnist. Mrs Caruana Galizia denies defaming the magistrate in a series of blog entries.
In an unusually short sitting, lasting only a few minutes, Magistrate Scerri Herrera described how she could not walk down the street without someone asking her if she had seen the latest blog about her.
The magistrate said the issue had also adversely affected her family, particularly her children. She recently found out that her fifth-form daughter was the only one in class who did not have a photo with her mother on popular social networking website Facebook.
One of her children was in the courtroom, attentively following her mother's testimony.
The magistrate said her daughter kept asking her when she could upload pictures, and she replied that she could not, ever. She had also asked her children to remove any Facebook pictures in which she featured.
Magistrate Scerri Herrera exhibited two decrees in which she abstained from hearing cases. The cases were Martin Degiorgio vs Daphne Caruana Galizia, and Daphne Caruana Galizia vs Kurt Farrugia, then editor of Maltastar.
She said she had taken the decisions alone and that the Chief Justice had never spoken to her about these cases.
The magistrate said that after her testimony at the last sitting, Assistant Commissioner Michael Cassar had contacted her to say he was not present at the dinner she had mentioned in a previous sitting. She said the dinner was not important at all but she was still under the impression that it was Mr Cassar who was present.
The case continues in May when Ms Caruana Galizia is expected to testify.
2 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
vincent magro
Apr 13th 2010, 20:07
Il-kariga ta magistrat hija puzizzjoni gholja hafna fis-socjeta,u ghandha jkollha ir-rispett kollu tal-politici,tal-gurnalisti u tal-poplu kollu in-generali.
Hija kariga li tenhtieg rekwiziti mhux biss akkademici u ta gustizza,izda wkoll ta mgieba tajba li tixraq lill-kariga ta dan il-generu.
Ir-responsabbilta tal-magistrat,ghalhekk,mhix biss lejn min appuntah,izda lejn il-poplu kollu li hu jistenna rispett minnhu.
U propju ghalhekk hemm il-kodici ta etika ghall-gudikatura,biex wiehed isegwieh,ghalkemm forsi mhux bil-punt u l-virgala,imma b'mod li wiehed ikun jidher u jinhass li b'mod genwin qed isegwi fis-sustanza dak il-kodici,ghax inkella jigrilna bhal-wiehed li ghadda mill-ezami tas-sewqan u tat-tejorija,imbghad isuq bl-addocc.
Issa f'kas li magistrat jikser dan il-kodici b'mod massigg,u gurnalist bhal Daphne jkollu l-kuragg 'u l-hila' li jgib dan ghall-attenzjoni tal-publiku,x'ghandna nghamlu ahna?Nghidu kemm hi kiesha dephne u kemm tindahal fejn ma jesahhiex?Jew nirringrazzjawa ghax gabet ghal-attenzjoni ta kullhadd imgieba hazina ta magistrat,u li ghalhekk qieghda ssir hsara lis-sistema gudizzjarja kolla?
Jekk l-allegazzjonijiet humiex minnhom jew le,ghad irridu naraw,izda l-bierah spiccat ix-xieda taghha Consuelo,u ma rribattietx l-akkuzi l-aktar serji li ghamlet fuqha Dephne.
Jien lili ma jinteressanix jekk tixbahx lill-warrani ta xarabank,li fil-fehema tieghi kien kumment zejjed.
Izda li jiteressani hu jekk id-dbatija li qieghdin ibatu l-magistrat u bintha,hijiex htija tal-gideb Dephne,jew htija ta mgieba hazina tal-magistrat
Graham Crocker
Apr 14th 2010, 00:21
"u ma rribattietx l-akkuzi l-aktar serji li ghamlet fuqha Daphne"
Your answer is here. You cannot win a libel case if you the accused proves he/she is saying the truth.