MEPs should help remove censorship
Malta's MEPs have been asked to help remove censorship by raising the issue in the European Parliament, to ensure the islands enjoyed the most fundamental European freedoms.
The Front Against Censorship sent the MEPs a letter this week with its proposals for changes in the law. It said last year would be remembered for Malta's actions against freedom of speech through "draconian" actions such as the punishment of carnival revellers, the ban of a play and the persecution of a newspaper editor.
The Front was set up in reaction to these events and now has more than 3,800 members. It said censorship of the arts and entertainment went against the core European principles of liberty and freedom of expression.
"This, however, does not mean we believe in a lawless state. On the contrary, we wholeheartedly believe laws should be there to protect citizens but not to be used as a force that restricts criticism and/or punishes innovative artists."
"We are humbly urging you to present this state of affairs to the European Parliament to raise the alarm on a European level regarding Malta's repressive and outdated censorship laws."
The Front said it was not in favour of any form of discrimination, exploitation or hate speech as defined by law, and neither did it believe that the removal of censorship would allow such acts to increase unregulated.
It believed punishing artistes for being critical of the Catholic Church or banning plays for what moralists may perceive to be "bad taste" were totally unacceptable in a European country in 2010.
9 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Andrew Farrugia
Apr 1st 2010, 19:47
It is not the Maltese state or the authorities that practice censorship in Malta. The worst form of censorship is that practiced by the media and particularly newspapers that have hidden agendas and adopt a particularly selective obscurantist policy which they can justify on the grounds of whimsical editorial policy. Shame.
Lawrence Fenech
Apr 1st 2010, 16:35
MEP's should also help to remove the Valletta project.
Martin Cassar
Apr 1st 2010, 14:36
Absolute democracy and absolute freedom of expression never existed anywhere in the world at any given point of time. All democracies have must have censorship (Laws) for self-protection and to protect the society at large.
Can anyone please mention just ONE SINGLE COUNTRY where absolute democracy and freedom of expression exists?
Robert Agius
Apr 1st 2010, 17:53
Absolute democracy is something that will always be in progress and the idea of ever attaining its is impossible. However, perhaps you are asking the wrong questions. When has something 'artistic' or words ever done harm to anyone. In most cases around the world freedom of expression is mainly limited as a defense against instigation. So much so that all constitutions include punishment for anyone who instigates to murder the president for example. I however believe that actions and word are VERY different and unless one is capable of restricting his actions then we are still waiting for the age of reason.
Words, picture etc. might have offended but NEVER harmed anyone.
Also note the following, I believe they are still part of our constitution.
(2) The authorities of the Roman Catholic Apostolic Church
have the duty and the right to teach which principles are right and
which are wrong.
(3) Religious teaching of the Roman Catholic Apostolic Faith
shall be provided in all State schools as part of compulsory
education.
Perhaps we still are waiting for the age of reason.
Martin Cassar
Apr 1st 2010, 18:46
Can I establish a business that print and sells stickers reading ‘I LOVE HITLER’ or ‘I AM A FASCIST’? Or a sticker reading Can I have any of such stickers on my private car windscreen please? Can I qualifies such stickers as a work of art?
I am European to the core and could never be counted as a Holocaust’s denial-my question: would MEPA give me a permission to establish a Kebab outlet with business trade mark [Shoah]? Such exercises are prohibited across Europe and are very much welcomed in Iran. Shall I take it then Iran is a step forward as far as freedom of expressions is concerned?
Is something like that allowed anywhere in Europe? Yes we are talking about 'art-works' and again no one is killed and no harm is done…what do u think?
Robert Agius
Apr 1st 2010, 19:30
I would hope that with the age of reason things such as the things you mention would not even be thought. Funny you mention 'I love Hitler' sticker for example because you find many Neo Nazi movements around the globe unfortunately and only in Germany is it illegal as far as I know.
Art will never be qualified. What Art is will NEVER be answered. Printing stickers however is business. Business and marketing are not are and I at least can see that difference (even though I admit in the latter its very difficult because Art seems to have more to do with marketing and advertising nowadays). If one opens such a business I guess they will come to reason once their business fails (as I would hope in a rational world).
Hey at least things will be in the open and people would have an idea of how some people think rather than be suppressed and eventually things taking a drastic turn because no measures were taken to see why such people think in such perverted ways. Don't you agree? You do not change people's opinion by simply censoring them.
Robert Agius
Apr 1st 2010, 19:34
Please note however that the ideas you put forth have NOTHING to do with issues that regards certain actions being taken against a few people recently. VERY different in fact. I hope you are not willingly ignoring this.
K. Pullicino
Apr 1st 2010, 11:26
What censorship?
'It believed punishing artistes for being critical of the Catholic Church or banning plays for what moralists may perceive to be "bad taste"'
I'm pretty sure you can do that all you want in Malta.
I think someone is facing a court case... and wants to be let off, scot-free.
By the way, I'm not artist, but I can tell that art leaves much to be desired in Malta... and it has nothing to do with censorship.
Norman Lowell
Apr 1st 2010, 10:27
The exquisite insouciance, the hypocrisy.
I was given a two year prison sentence for writing a politico/cultural article:
Coming Cataclysmic Crises - on the internet.
Not one, not a single champion of Freedom of Expression uttered a word of support.
Media, TV hosts, radio, newspapers - nobody stood up for REAL freedom of expression.
You hypocrites!