Advert

'Humiliating' strip-search on Gozo street

'Where is the presumption of innocence?'

A youth being searched during roadblocks held in Ċirkewwa on carnival weekend. Photo: Martin Agius, AFM

A youth being searched during roadblocks held in Ċirkewwa on carnival weekend. Photo: Martin Agius, AFM

An 18-year old has spoken of his "humiliation" while being strip-searched in the streets of Gozo during one of the roadblocks held on the island during carnival weekend.

It was the second roadblock the Birkirkara youth and his four male friends had encountered, having already been stopped and searched in Ċirkewwa before boarding the ferry.

Later, on their way to a party, they were stopped again by the Armed Forces where they felt the soldiers went too far.

Accompanied by his father when speaking to The Sunday Times, the youth recounted his story on condition of anonymity: "We were stopped in a side street. Without any greeting we were told to get out of the car. They started searching us and each one of us had to remove our clothing all the way down to our boxer shorts. The soldiers then stuck their foot between our heels to force our legs open and they searched us.

"We were told if we did not cooperate we would be passed on to the police for questioning," he said, adding that the soldiers were difficult to identify because, unlike police, they did not have ID numbers on their clothing.

Nothing incriminating was found following the thorough search - as was the case for several others who said they were repeatedly targeted for searches.

The stories emerged after this newspaper last week reported that the European Court of Human Rights declared police stop and search powers in the UK - broadly similar to those given to the police and army in Malta - were illegal because they violated an individual's right to privacy.

In last January's ruling, the ECHR said such powers led to discrimination because people were stopped on the basis of a "hunch" or "professional intuition".

This was confirmed by a number of individuals who approached The Sunday Times following the publication of last week's story. All were aged under 30, and in each case nothing had been found during inspection.

Lionel Brincat, 24, from Pietà, was also stopped in the Ċirkewwa AFM roadblocks on carnival weekend, although it was not his first experience.

He recalled one incident where, after he was frisked, the soldiers handed back his wallet open, and money fell out. Mr Brincat claimed he was accused of throwing drugs out of the wallet and told he would be detained. Feeling "abused" because he never touched drugs, he said he was relieved when the commanding officer eventually let him go.

"I could not understand where he thought I could have been hiding the drugs when I had already been frisked and my pockets and wallet searched. I really felt humiliated that night... but I did not dare complain," he added.

Ryan Falzon and Eve Wilkson said their experiences over the years led them to believe soldiers were stopping people just on the grounds of age and appearance. They also accused soldiers of targeting people from particular areas.

Ms Wilkinson, 21, said she had lost count how often they had been stopped.

"When we are with Ryan's modified car we are always stopped, but when we are with my Mercedes we are not. And when we used to live in Qormi, roadblocks were regular. Now we live in Naxxar, it barely happens," Ms Wilkinson said.

But they got stopped earlier this month, on their way to visit her boyfriend's grandmother in Rabat, with younger relatives in the car.

The five people in the car had to wait for almost an hour until it was their turn to be searched. They were forced to keep their windows closed for the entire time and ordered not to use their mobile phones while a soldier stood on guard. This procedure was verified by all those who spoke to this newspaper.

Her boyfriend, a 23-year-old university law student, said: "It is our right to answer our phones. We were not under arrest. Where is the presumption of innocence?"

Online reactions to The Sunday Times' story last week included comments by those favouring roadblocks, based on the notion that "those who have nothing to hide have nothing to fear".

Mr Falzon said these arguments were normally made by those who had never been stopped and searched.

"They are targeting youths, according to their idea of who could be a potential criminal," he said.

His comments were in line with reader John Borg's view: "The process is discriminatory. I am never stopped in roadblocks but my son is regularly subjected to frisking. They are easy prey because they do not know their rights. If done legitimately, every parent should be grateful, but where is the 'reasonable suspicion' in all this?"

Mr Borg objected to the military doing police work: "This is not a war zone. Why are the soldiers getting involved?"

The AFM said roadblocks are conducted apropriately as required in support of local law enforcement authorities, adding that discretion is applied professionally when sampling vehicles and/or people to be checked. Home Affairs Minister Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici last week said the ECHR ruling did not "at face value" change Maltese law, because stop and search powers could only be exercised if the police had 'reasonable suspicion'. The minister said if somebody felt aggrieved, he had the right to seek redress.

But leading criminal lawyers said this legal remedy was not proving effective.

cmuscat@timesofmalta.com

Advert

41 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Christian Sciberras

Mar 29th 2010, 17:07

15 mins in a cold environment? Are you lying?
It takes me anything between 30 to 45 minutes to get to my Maltese destinations, with all windows closed, during winter of course.

Joseph Vassallo

Mar 30th 2010, 18:33

"The search extends to uncomfortable areas of the body, especially for women." That would constitute an assault (possibly sexual abuse) and I do not believe for a second that the AFM do this; I suggest respectfully that you substantiate your allegation by asking the woman/women in question to come forward with a formal complaint or desist from making such allegations as if they were just run-of-the-mill behaviour that is acceptable to the citizens of this little nation.

I also suggest that the armed forces and police only stop people who are behaving erratically causing suspicion that the occupants are under the influence of alcohol or drugs (e.g. driving over the centre line when taking a bend, weaving from lane to lane or maybe overtaking long lines of traffic). Of course, the breathaliser has to be used by a competent officers not junior ranks who might not be answerable. I've seen drivers being breathalised for much less in UK (e.g. driving too slowly ).

I would also expect the police to investigate the veracity of the recent allegations of public strip-searches and to take action against whomsoever is found to be at fault. Rebut or confirm.

Christian Sciberras

Mar 29th 2010, 17:08

Because common sense is not so common?

G.Debono

Mar 28th 2010, 23:41

Can somebody translate what this person is saying? Is he for or against...buq...cannot understand him.

Christian Sciberras

Mar 29th 2010, 17:10

Apparently traffic accidents (blamed on wet roads) is also the "NORM".

Wilfred L Camilleri

Mar 28th 2010, 14:40

Mr. Oatmon, using soldiers for random roadblocks and searches is abuse of the right to privacy as declared by the ECHR. It is another matter if there is suspicion of a law being broken and then it's the police who should be doing it not the armed forces. These are tactics used by totalitarian and repressive states, such as China and the old USSR. There is no room for random roadblocks by armed military personnel in a democratic society and a peaceful nation.

Advert
Advert