• email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

MP loses his cool at basketball match

David Agius (right) watching yesterday's basketball game between Luxol and Depiro. Photo: Jason Borg

Spectators at a competition basketball game last Thursday witnessed what they thought was just another random argument, peppered with foul language, but were then surprised to see that one of the protagonists losing his temper was PN Parliamentary whip David Agius.

In a letter he sent to The Times, a spectator, Charles Sammut said two policemen had to intervene to calm down Mr Agius, who was using obscene language.

Another spectator, Daniela Cassar, said Mr Agius had used "a colourful array of language", adding that the altercation was "hilarious until I realised who it was". The MP yesterday admitted losing his temper after he was "provoked" by another spectator who passed a barbed comment about him having cheated in his university exams, but said he could not recall using foul language.

He said he was "not the type to use that kind of language" although he was not going to argue about whether he did so or not since he was angry and hurt at the time.

"I felt hurt, offended and insulted," he told The Times yesterday.

Asked whether he regretted losing his temper, Mr Aguis answered: "Isn't it obvious that I regret it? But afterwards everyone's sorry."

The incident took place during a game at Ta' Qali pavilion between Siġġiewi, of which club Mr Agius is president, and Sliema. At one point, a spectator, whose son plays for Sliema, passed a comment to the 41-year-old parliamentarian, who was watching the game with one of his two young daughters.

"He said: 'Why don't you go copy rather than come watch basketball.' Naturally, I reacted and told him that if he wanted to say something unrelated to sport, he should not say it there but outside," Mr Agius said.

He continued that the "wound was still fresh" since the incident happened two days after media reports that he had copied in his university exams.

The claim about him cheating in an undergraduate exam surfaced in an alleged blackmail attempt against Mr Agius just before the general election in March last year. Mr Agius opted to take the matter to the courts. However, as part of the same proceedings, the story was back in the news last week.

"Imagine if my father or mother had just died and somebody offended them. It hurts that he did it on purpose because his son's team was losing. You don't do these things in sport," he said, adding that the man repeated his "provocation" after the game, as everyone was leaving the pavilion. Attempts to contact the spectator yesterday were futile.

When it was pointed out that being a politician made him a role model and he should have kept his cool, Mr Agius answered: "Yes, but I'm also human."

Mr Agius said he always tried to keep politics and basketball separate. "Whenever I get into the Ta' Qali pavilion, I remove my political hat and don't even go to the VIP stand because I don't feel I'm anything but the club president.

"Maybe I overreacted but I also have the right to defend myself and to say that politics and sports should not be mixed," he said, adding that in five years as the Siġġiewi club's president and 25 years playing basketball, he had never had any problems.

Ms Cassar said she approached Mr Agius during the game and told him that he should be ashamed of himself for reacting like that. She said the parliamentarian put his hand on her shoulder although he denied touching her.

Later a policeman told the young woman not to provoke anyone and even took her particulars, but Mr Agius yesterday said he gave instructions for no action to be taken against her.

  • Google Bookmarks Del.icio.us Facebook Blogger YahooMyWeb Digg Reddit Stumbleupon
  • email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Comments

Stephen Sammut Nurminen (on 5/12/09)
The limits of acceptable criticism are accordingly wider as regards a politician as such than as regards a private individual. Unlike the latter, the former inevitably and knowingly lays himself open to close scrutiny of his every word and deed by both journalists and the public at large, and he must consequently display a greater degree of tolerance.

No doubt Article 10 para. 2 (art. 10-2) enables the reputation of others - that is to say, of all individuals - to be protected, and this protection extends to politicians too, even when they are not acting in their private capacity; but in such cases the requirements of such protection have to be weighed in relation to the interests of open discussion of political issues.
Jeremy J Camilleri (on 2/12/09)
James Formosa...no bloggers here...just commentators...

WHilst anyone can make a mistake...it seems that David AGius has made a mistake, and a mistake, and a mistake....

R. Zammit (on 1/12/09)
Fine it’s a mistake! No big deal. Are there any humans who do not err? My concern is not that….what worried me was QUOTE “Later a policeman told the young woman not to provoke anyone and even took her particulars, but Mr Agius yesterday said he gave instructions for no action to be taken against her” Unquote. What is this? instructing a policeman not to carry out his duty according to his obligations?? Are we still living with this dilemma?
James Formosa (on 1/12/09)
@All bloggers ....without sin among you, let them first cast a stone at....him!!! He reacted to provocation and should not have!! He lost it and made a mistake - he should publicly apologise (not to the dim-wit that provoked him) but to everyone else and move on. He's a politician and a sports fan (in this case) NOT the Pope.
charles camilleri (on 1/12/09)
I was there for the game as a spectator and David Agius was provked before he reacted. The truth is that whenever Siggiewi is on the winning side provocation is continuous and obscene languae is thrown at Siggiewi players and the coach, the spectators and the president of the club, David Agius, but that is all blessed since it is comming from anyone else but siggiewi side. Has He never used foul language and has he never been stupid in his reasoning. We are the best when judging others. Well done David you had done what anyone else would have done in such a circumtance Keep it up Siggiewi and let the provocation make you stronger
Joe E Galea (on 1/12/09)
What beats me is the fact that PN blue-eyed bootlickers see nothing wrong in any wrongdoing by their PN idols and when a PL memebr sneezes it's the end of the world. These people would better to get real and get a life.
Jeremy J Camilleri (on 1/12/09)
Ps....is he part of the party that waged a war against magistrates for being involved in sports activities?
Jeremy J Camilleri (on 1/12/09)
Yes Joe SPiteri..SOme of us have lost our temper...but then again, an Mp's wages and benefits might go a long way in helping me control it....

So the temper bits answered...now lets see...copying? Three times? Nah...havn't done that...
antoinette micallef (on 1/12/09)
Ma jifilhux jaraw lit team tas Siggiewi jirbah.KEEP IT UP SIGGIEWI KENT BORINGER.
Joe Portelli (on 1/12/09)
ehmm , " because I don't feel I'm anything but the club president '"


OHH, I seeee.

Politics and Sports is like Oil & Water (DON'T MIX) no matter what .

Let the sportsman be sportsmen , cause the politician is certainly not sports when provoked!
Joe Spiteri (on 30/11/09)
Is there anybody out there who has never lost his temper? More so if provoked in public by a stranger? I think it occasionally happens to each and everyone of us even when children are present. It’s an automatic reaction which is difficult to control. It happened to other politicians in the past – even of a higher stature than Mr Agius. All this talk about this incident is solely due to Mr Agius being an MP. Perhaps we’re making mountains out of molehills.
Jeremy J Camilleri (on 30/11/09)
NO C camilleri is right...being an MP is just about extra benefits, and NOT extra responsabilities....
c. camilleri (on 30/11/09)
David is human like any other person and if provoked he would react like anyone of us. Being an MP does not make him a Saint and definitely is not immuned from over reacting to provocation . Why all this fuss about? I think David did the wrong way in not taking action for defamation against the lady. She will do it again if she had the chance.
E. Vassallo (on 30/11/09)
Two seperate issues should not be mixed in any event let alone a leisurely one such as basketball. I really wonder how such persons vent their frustration by resorting to such cowardice tactics. This shows the true spirit of bad losers.
David Thake (on 30/11/09)
@P Dingli I have heard Police Officers use foul language whilst on duty. I doubt that I am alone. I also cannot walk for an hour without hearing someone blaspheme - often within earshot of the law - with amazing creativity. I doubt that there would be many spectators left on the Ta Qali stands where the Police to book every offender noble as that idea is. @ Charles Sammut. The glass houses idiom means don't criticize other people when you yourself have faults and weaknesses. Since you seem to object to its use with regards to your sensational reaction to David Agius' outburst am I to assume that you have no faults or weakness? Do I think that all people in authority should be snow white and perfect? Yes. Am I surprised that they are prone to human error? No Is this a mistake that should disqualify David Aguis from being an MP? Please.....
Charles Sammut (on 30/11/09)
@N.Calleja, I might agree with you,if this debaucle were reported in the Orizzont or Kulhadd... but it was sent to ( and printed in ) the Times of Malta and timesofmalta.com. , so I think you are somewhat confusing the issue of the "media machines throwing mud" ! It is a known fact that the protagonist is Nationalist backbencher.
The "people in glass houses" saying is also being confused and erroneously used.
The incident involved a Political person but it had nothing to do with politics.
And you are correct...it was a stupid incident !
N.Calleja (on 30/11/09)
This stupid incident ,which happens repeatedly in all sport venues, simply shows that the two parties' media machines enjoy carrying such banal incidents to throw mud at each other. As if people in glass houses can throw stones. It is becoming a regular feature in every news bulletin to pick on some member of parliament, minister etc and expose him to disrespect. Is this the new way of doing politics. Maltese politics should learn to have some respect. Unfortunately broadcasting pluralism is not serving well the maturity the nation needs so badly.
P. Dingli (on 30/11/09)
@David Thake

I do agree on the spirit of what you are saying.

However the fact is that the Police do charge people for swearing especially during football matches.

So is this a question of two weights and two measures?
Dr. Mark A. Sammut (on 30/11/09)
Joe Cassar (4 hours, 31 minutes ago)
Now what was that word people use in such circumstances, rev....., no, ret......, no rem ..... Oh, yes; "resignation".

With all due respect: why should anyone RESIGN just because they lost their temper? Since when is losing one's temper a crime or a misdemeanour?

Mr Agius lost his temper - like all those of true Mediterranean temperament. He was provoked. That is understandable. Perhaps he overreacted. That too is understandable.

He should just apologize, and life goes on. If he broke any law then he should be prosecuted. But if he broke no law - and there is no law saying that you cannot lose your cool - then this is an overreaction by readers!

All this talk of resignations here and resignations there for the flimsiest of reasons is not acceptable in a democracy. It smacks of LYNCHING.
Charles DeMicoli (on 30/11/09)
In any other democratic country, Mr. MP would be hounded by the press until he was made to pay the price for his own, voluntary action. But this is Malta, everything gets swept under the rug. Fuhgettaboutit!
David Thake (on 30/11/09)
I have also used colourful language when i have on occasion lost my temper. Does that make me a bad parent?

People in glass houses should not throw stones. And please, if anyone is about to say that they have never uttered a rude word.... spare us the charade.

David is an excellent MP and yes, he lost his temper. He remains an excellent MP.
Joe Busuttil (on 30/11/09)
If foul language was used the police should take action against whoever uttered it. As regards politicians ' right to a private life,I think that they renounce to it once they enter public life. Their behaviour should always be under a magnifying lens so that if there are cases of corruption etc etc etc , the common folks will be aware of it. If you can't keep your cool Mr Whip give up your political career.
sandro pace (on 30/11/09)
I am no fan of Mr. Agius, but PL should fight the PN with other means (and there are lots of them), not with such character assasinations on individuals. Politics are politics, but capitalising too much on human weakness of the moment is morally debatable. And will obviously bounce back, cause I am sure that the PL parliamentary group contains both saints and sinners.

It seems that punitive measures were already taken against Mr. Agius at the University, he admitted and apologised about it. So it's not that Mr. Agius should be continually touted about it everytime he goes somewhere. It smacks of ignorance. However, an intellectual 'match' would be more appropriate in such cases instead of resorting to alleged foul language. The true ignorant will emerge.

Maradona and Henry both cheated some time in their life. But they are still much better footballers than anyone who would make it a mission in life to continously reminding them about it in a publicly derogative way. Not to justify any cheating, but there are limits in everything.
Stephen Spiteri (on 30/11/09)
"He could not recall using foul language". Two people said he did. The police officers present could also elucidate whether he did or not. Who shall we believe ?
Charles Sammut (on 30/11/09)
" Mr.Agius gave instructions ( to the police ) for no action to be taken against her ( Dr.Daniela Cassar)." ...Action for what, for chiding him for his bad and crude behaviour?
Is Mr.Agius, Minister of Police?
To Malcolm Farrugia, I say yes..his own daughter was with him.
To Joe Cassar, I say...dream on!!

By the way..I am THE Charles Sammut who wrote the article to the TIMES.
As I always say, more Maltese citizens ought to put pen to paper and air their comments/ views.
Stephen Sammut nurminen (on 30/11/09)
Yes there were children watching the match, including Mr Agius' own kids (good example)

Also, wasn't aware that action could be taken against Ms Cassar, as no foul language or threats were directed towards Mr Agius, she merely expressed her disgust at his behaviour, rightly so.

david calleja (on 30/11/09)
@Victor Laiviera
Agreed totally - i was under the impression that only Police officials could ''give'' instructions to other Policemen / women?.... since when to MPs have this ''authority''??
Malcolm Farrugia (on 30/11/09)
Prosit Mr Agius for the exellent example you gave(pun intended), where there any children in the pavillion?
Joe Grima (on 30/11/09)
Politicians are expected to accept insults, hate mail, snide remarks and spit in the face and act like a Jesus Christ on the Cross. Politicians are human beings too, have feelings, have families who suffer for them and with them when the insults come flying. They are not trained to grin and bear it and react like heroes. David Agius is a decent Nationalist who has to succumb to the kind of politics that Nationalists and Labourites practice everyday on each other - character assasination at its best. David made a mistake when he was young. Who in the world hasn't? Until he became LP leader Joseph Muscat was igniored by the Nationalist media. Now he is an everyday target for all kinds of sins of commission and omission. When Dr Gonzi became Leader of the PN, he promised a new way of doing politics He did not. On his election to the LP leadership, Joseph Muscat too promised a new style of doing politics. The radio and TV stations of both Parties are acting against the declared policy of their leaders and should be brought in line. Politicians from both Parties are entitled to a peaceful private life too.
ASpiteri (on 30/11/09)
hahaha...the present day political class...no surprise this country is in shambles!
Joe Cassar (on 30/11/09)
Now what was that word people use in such circumstances, rev....., no, ret......, no rem ..... Oh, yes; "resignation".
Victor Laiviera (on 30/11/09)
"Mr Agius yesterday said he gave instructions (to the police) for no action to be taken against her."

Since when do the police "take instructions" on when and how to do thgeir duties?

Poll

Do you agree with the compensation that is being given to the bus owners?

  • yes
  • no
  • don't know
  • don't care


View results

Fun Stuff


Play Sudoku