Tuesday, 17th November 2009
Karozzini: Experts call for better management of horses
"Animal-loving tourists get the wrong impression when they see these animals spending a whole day in the sun without adequate shade or drinking water". Photo: Chris Sant Fournier
Horse-drawn carriages should be treated as an endangered species since they are a part of Maltese tradition that ought to be better looked after, according to two British animal welfare experts.
"The Maltese horses are well treated by their owners. We are not concerned with the condition of the horses but with the management system," veterinary surgeon Carl Boyde said.
His colleague Ramsay Hovell, a professor specialising in transport animals, said the authorities needed to improve the management of the karozzini on the road and the conditions in which the horses work.
The horses need shelter that covers their entire bodies while they wait for custom during the hot summer months, as well as drinking water and better hygiene.
But for this to happen, the experts said, there needed to be a greater effort and better coordination between the various ministers that represent tourism transport, roads and animal welfare.
The experts stressed that the horse owners were playing their part and it was now up to the authorities to work together for the welfare of the animals. The subject has been the centre of a battle on the part of animal rights associations at least for the past 10 years.
In fact, Dr Boyde and Prof. Hovell came to Malta last week at the request of the World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA), which was in turn responding to complaints by the local NGO Animal Rights' Group.
Their job is to assess the situation of the horses that operate the karozzini and they will now draw up a report, which will recommend to local authorities how to improve their conditions. Besides those of local animal rights groups, Dr Boyde explained that the WSPA had also received independent reports from tourists who felt sorry for the horses left waiting in the sweltering summer heat while holidaying in Malta.
"They are a tourist attraction and should be safeguarded," Dr Boyle said, adding that there were currently about 60 carriages in operation on the island.
"Animal-loving tourists get the wrong impression when they see these animals spending a whole day in the sun without adequate shade or drinking water," he said. This could result in dehydration that may even lead to the horse collapsing.
He added that most carriage owners had more than one horse and rotated the animals to ensure they were not overworked.
Apart from that, the actual carriages were light.
The owners were doing their best. Now it was up to the authorities to work together to ensure the welfare of the animals, Prof. Hovell said.
During their visit to Malta the two men observed the state of the horse-drawn carriages in various parts of the island including the Valletta Waterfront and Mdina.
They also held meetings with representatives of the Floriana local council (under which the Valletta Waterfront falls), Animal Welfare Department, the General Workers' Union (that represents the kartozzini owners) and the Transport Ministry.
The first move to protect the animals from the summer sun came in 2005, when the government set up provisional shelters in St George's Square, in Valletta. However, these were criticised for being too few.
Eventually, however, even these shelters were dismantled in August when horse-drawn cab drivers were stopped from entering the centre of Valletta so the area could be turned into a pedestrian zone as part of the government's Valletta rehabilitation project.
Cab stands were temporarily relocated in various areas on the outskirts of the capital where there are no shelters yet. In fact, ever since this move, animal rights organisations have again called on government to provide shade and drinking water to these animals.
The government has said that the transport and tourism authorities were discussing the possibility of setting up shelters around the city.
RSS
Comments
No need for millions of euros as in other projects ! What is needed is a get-together of the ministers concerned with the horse-owners so that the government provides these long-awaited horse shelters.
The goverment would be directly helping to protect and upkeep a centuries' old tradition and tourist attraction of our country.
This situation is shameful and something MUST be done sooner rather than later, before summer arrives again.
stopped passing the buck and agreed to do something concrete to better the atrocious conditions these horses face in summer. We are too concerned with looking 'nice and neat' - and forget that the horses suffer. If the karozzini horses (and I don't mean the owners!) had a union, they would long ago have gone on strike.
While we have this tradition, let's ensure that the animals are well taken care of.
All the people complaining about urine...that's exactly why we need better hygiene facilities.
I really hope that just as we found 200,000 euros in the budget to increase the amount of fountains locally, we can find some money to ensure another water source from which the horses can be quenched together with a permanent shelter and better hygienic facilities so that this problem is resolved once and for all.
From the side of the public there has been a clear perception that there is no real framework or strategy in the improvement of these facilities for horse carriages. Which to me comes to show the lack of coordinated efforts between the different entities in the issue. ADT, animal Welfare department, tourism authority etc. I mean even the shelters clashed with the Public works department and has to be moved.
This issue goes beyond the animal welfare but hi lights the exclusion of this 'traditional' service from the strategy of Malta from a tourism perspective. It also shows the vacuum in which these cabs operate where they just take over half of the entrance to Valletta for their Cabs. Something needs to be done about this!
Government ministries ovbiously prefare avoiding the subject for another winter as it has done in previous years. Hoping that the winter time will cool the spirits of who supports animal rights. but hopefully this year we will see the end of this!
Unfortunately, cultural behaviour and mores are near impossible to alter and improve. It's the nature of the beast. Sometimes, unless the local people expose their government internationally, nothing will ever get done. This is not an attribute exclusive to Malta. In this light, monies spent to bring Dr Boyde and Prof. Hovell over to Malta for a visit and ask them to give their professional assessment on the state of these unfortunate animals will not be in vain (hopefully).
Certainly not with regard to the mess of facaes left behind on many a street around our capital city or for that matter any other location in Malta. An attempt to put some order to control this mess some years ago was welcomed with sheer disregard by cab owners/drivers.
Cab owners/drivers must realise that besides rights they have also obligations towards society in general.