Ex-PN heavyweights support Gonzi's call for National Day, but Sant dubs it a 'trick'
Preparations for Independence Day celebrations were in full swing on the Granaries in Floriana yesterday. Photo: Darrin Zammit Lupi
The Prime Minister's call to make Independence Day Malta's one National Day has been welcomed by former Nationalist Party heavyweights but denounced as a "trick" by ex-Labour leader Alfred Sant.
Malta currently has five national days, but there has been a concerted effort to try and select one date which can be celebrated in a non-partisan manner.
When contacted, Dr Sant - who has refused to make any comments unrelated to his writing for several months - told The Sunday Times: "This is the usual trick by the Prime Minister to deviate from the country's problems.
"It also shows that the PN wants to have its way on everything," he added, without going into the merits of which day should be chosen as the National Day.
On the other hand, former PN leader and President Emeritus Eddie Fenech Adami said he agreed completely with Lawrence Gonzi since Independence Day was "undoubtedly" the most important date in Malta's political development. Dr Fenech Adami said that in the past he had tried in vain to persuade other politicians to choose one National Day, but he was always convinced that in terms of Malta's Constitutional development, Independence Day was the natural choice.
"This does not mean the others will be eliminated, but everyone should recognise the most important day in our history," he said.
President Emeritus Guido de Marco also said he was in favour of making September 21 Malta's one National Holiday.
Prof. de Marco added that political leaders could not agree on one national date in the past, but as the country was maturing the time was now approaching ripeness to make this step.
Unlike Victory Day, which celebrated the Maltese efforts for sovereignty in collaboration with both the Knights and the British, Independence Day celebrated the effort of the Maltese alone, Prof. de Marco said.
"Independence Day is the day a country is born.
"However, we need to use the politics of persuasion because this is not something that can be imposed.
"We have to be careful not to have division," he said, appealing to both parties to come to an agreement on the matter.
A similar appeal was made by President George Abela and Archbishop Paul Cremona who both called for an agreement to be reached that expressed the will of the Maltese public. However, they were both careful not to take a stand or influence the debate.
Mgr Cremona said this was a "political decision" which should be left to the politicians and the public, but added that if an agreement were to be reached "it would be better to have one national day like other countries".
Dr Abela said his role in this discussion was to be a "moderator" and to find a day with the right historical and political value, but one that also created unity.
"We need to reach national consensus," he said.
Till now, the discussion has mainly revolved around three dates: Independence Day, which celebrates Malta's independence from British rule in 1964; Victory Day on September 8 which jointly coincides with the victory over the Turks in the 1565 Great Siege and the island's perseverance against the World War II bombers; and Freedom Day on March 31 which is when British forces left the island for good.
Although Independence Day is generally associated with and celebrated by the PN, one Labour exponent, Desmond Zammit Marmarà, has made the case for it to become Malta's one National Holiday since it was not a victory only won by the PN.
Meanwhile, PN MP Charlo Bonnici, said that although he would prefer Independence Day, past events had "jeopardised" this possibility because most Labourites would not accept it as a unifying day without partisan connotations. He said Victory Day would be the second-best option.
Despite several attempts, The Sunday Times could not reach former Labour leaders Dom Mintoff and Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici for their comments.
On the eve of Independence Day, Juan Ameen heard what people had to say on whether September 21 should be the one National Day.
Mary Grace Borg, from Paola.
"Yes I agree - it should be Independence Day."
Adolf Attard, from Pieta.
"I agree that we should have one day and it should be Independence Day. It is the country's national feast."
Paul Said, from St Venera.
"We should have one - it should be Sette Giugno."
John Calleja, from Valletta.
"I think the National Day should be celebrated on the day that you were born. Without Independence Day, we would not have the other national holidays.
Lourdes Chircop from Valletta.
"I think it should be Independence Day. This government deserves it as George Borg Olivier worked hard for it."
Roberto Chiappa from Żejtun.
"I don't agree that we just have one National Day - what will happen to the others? They have been National Days for so long."
7 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Anthony Mizzi
Sep 21st 2009, 07:04
National consensus is needed and not Nationalist Party sustainers, Nationalist Party big heads and Nationalist Party MPs ' imposition.
One tends to agree that Independence Day is the day a country is born but this is a generic statement
Locally our 21st September "Independence" has always been "CONTROLLED INDEPENDENCE" and a controlled independence is no Independence at all .
Jesmond Micallef
Sep 20th 2009, 21:19
Why should Malta argue about such an important milestone in the history of the Maltese Islands ??? WE DID NOT OBTAIN INDEPENDENCE FROM EACHOTHER BUT FROM OUR BRITISH OCCUPIERS !!!!!
COMMON GROUND PLEASE !!!!!! May I also add that Independence should also mean Psychological Independence too
Paul Barrett
Sep 20th 2009, 16:38
When it comes to the crunch what real difference does it make - as long as it is a Public Holiday - i.e., a day off work to be with the family (ideally on the beach) or if working, at least getting extra money for it.
Charles Zammit
Sep 20th 2009, 15:28
These are undoubtedly distraction tactics. Divide and rule as the saying goes. Gonzipn seeing that the people are fed up with it are trying to create a mountain out of a molehill. What the people are concerned most about are the price of water and electricity, cost of living, poor health services, the threat to their social services, poor attention to the environment, declining tourism, exploitation of the workers especially by employers who acquire companies from the government for a pittance, institutionalised corruption and much more.
That Dr. Fenech Adami steps in to give a helping hand to Gonzi comes with no surprise after all much of the problems inherited by Gonzi are of his own making. If memory does not play tricks on me the vast majority of the house (Dr. Fenech Adami included) had voted for the Republic when the bill was brought before the house of representatives. In my view this cannot be discarded. It was just about the only occasion when there was quasi unanimous agreement on an issue that carried so much importance to the nation. This was the real birth of the nation not the so called independence.
Eric Gahn
Sep 20th 2009, 15:04
IF there should only be one national day it should be Republic Day. We are The REPUBLIC of Malta not the 'Free Island State of Malta' of 'Independent State of Malta'. 13th December is the day.
Robert Callus
Sep 20th 2009, 12:12
I agree with Dr Sant on this. Malta (and the whole world) are passing through hard times, especially due to the recession and serious environmental problems. Focus should be on surviving these realities with the least scratches.
Apart from alienation, this is also part of the divide and rule mentality the PNPL have been using. Though I find it ridiculous that Independence day is 'PN's day while Freedom Day is the 'PL's day, reality is that diehards from both parties still view it that way. I see this as a deliberate attempt to cause friction and divide the Maltese people.
Ronald Camilleri
Sep 20th 2009, 11:32
don't we have more rooted problems than choosing a national day??
unemployment, deficit, mater dei, rising cost of living and inflation, vat scandals, building an (OLD) new power station with a 2% (4 million euros) commission in a single pocket et al.
l-aqwa li naljenaw il-poplu!! din ghandha news value!! halluna....
as for the timesofmalta, the issue of National Day was given more prominence than the motion raised in parliament yesterday with allegations of misappropriation in the contract awarded to BWSCfor the new power station in delimara.
i can already smell the times prior next election .......
wear your badge "the times" please!!