Mepa to remain involved in policy formulation
The government is considering establishing time frames for the validation process of permits, some of which would be determined by the applicants.
Moreover, Mepa would remain involved in formulating planning and environmental policy, Parliamentary Secretary Mario de Marco, who is responsible for the reform, said this morning.
The proposed reform of the Malta Environment and Planning Authority is currently being debated in a national conference held as part of the consultation process.
Various stakeholders, including non-governmental organisations, Mepa employees and construction workers, are taking part. Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi is present.
Very slight changes have been made to the original reform document, the most significant one being that the proposed voluntary screening process would be given a four week term.
Those present put across their grievances, positions and opinions.
Dr de Marco said that the reform was not one of just one entity because planning and the environment were part of every sector.
He said that ironically, the main criticism being made was that the government was reducing Mepa’s power to decide on development policy.
This was a certificate of confidence in the authority’s operations. For while the people wanted a change in Mepa, they wanted a change which would strengthen, rather than weaken the institution.
He said that the people’s participation in the process was strong and a number of consultative meetings had been held. These had led to the drawing up of the document “A Blueprint for Mepa’s Reform”.
Other meetings were held following the publication of the document and the people’s views and opinions were again received. The conference being held today was a continuation of the consultation process.
The conference was also an opportunity to stock take the proposals received, which the government was analysing in detail.
Architect Robert Musumerci pointed out that he did not agree with the idea proposed that case law would be ignored.
Mepa assistant director in the Environment Unit, Marie Briguglio, said that the reform was not ambitious enough. She said it should have been more consistent with the authority’s name, environment not addressed enough.
Environmentalist Astrid Vella insisted that DCC board members should be scrutinised by the public before they were appointed.
People in the construction sector expressed worry that restricting development would it harder for small developers to obtain permits.
GRTU director general Vince Farrugia said that members on Mepa boards should not be appointed by the government but by a board of stake holders.
Former Mepa director general Godwin Cassar asked if politicians would be drawing up the structure plan or if they would just be giving the direction but it would be drawn up by experts.
Church Environment Commission chairman Victor Asciak said that the experience of the last 50 years had shown that politicians could not be trusted to have a long term vision. He suggested that DCC board members should be answerable to Parliament.
Former minister Michael Falzon asked how would the reform contribute to ensure consistency when it still allowed different case officers to interpret policy in different ways.
Former minister Jesmond Mugliett asked what would the environment be gaining from the proposed reform.
The Labour Party’s spokesman for the environment, Leo Brincat raised a number of questions mainly on enforcement and accountability.
4 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
S. Cutajar
Jul 31st 2009, 16:24
The biggest mistake in this MEPA "Reform?" is the lack of political will by Dr. Gonzi to decide to divide again the Planning directorate from the Environment directorate.
The biggest political mistake in recent history was the decision taken by the former minister for Environment George Pullicino when announcing the merger (or better) TAKEOVER by the then Planning Authority of the former Environment Protection Department on the 1 March 2003.
This decision brought a serious brain drain of the then limited personnel working in the environment sector from the former EPD. Instead of promoting ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION, Dr. Pullicino sent the wrong message to the country by deciding that there was no space for an ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AGENCY. He instead opted to demote further down the environment issues vis a vis the Planning issues. As a result of this wrong decision, the Director for Environment Protection was relegated to a mere observer (with no VOTE) in the MEPA DCC Board.
The failed result of the then much-hyped merger is for all to see!!!
E.A. Mallia
Jul 31st 2009, 13:20
This MEPA reform conference seems more like a collection of large bumble bees. So we have Musumeci not wanting to ignore case law--which if I understand it right means that if MEPA made issued an invalid permit, he (Musumeci) can demand that it issues another one. Astrid Vella insisted that DCC board members should be scrutinised by the public before appointment. Who defines "the public"? Godwin Cassar is worried about who draws up the structure plan, the politicians or the experts ? We can answer that when he tells us who drew up the 2006 development lines, the Cabinet or the experts?
Michael Falzon has got an overdose of "case officeritis". He seems quite unconcerned with the long history of case officers being over-ruled by boards. The instances were so numerous that either case officers were grossly incompetent or corrupt in the sense of wanting to foist their personal views on the planning process. Either way I have never heard Falzon complain in the long years he was MEPA's master. Neither did he say one word on what was a recent classic of board-case officer interaction: the Nadur cemetry on Gozo.
Joe Cassar
Jul 31st 2009, 12:13
"This was a certificate of confidence in the authority’s operations"
Was this for real??
Galea. L
Jul 31st 2009, 12:13
How could it remain in charge of policy formulation when it has consistently shown that it cannot be relied upon and has produced the most perverse results that ever happened in Malta?