• email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Editorial

Rising from the Royal Opera House ashes

The Royal Opera House was destroyed by a German aerial mine on April 7, 1942. This was a devastating blow that has left a physical and psychological scar on the face of Valletta from which it has still not recovered. The bombed-out ruin stands as a monument to the indecision, inertia and lack of political will of successive governments for the past 67 years.

At last, however, this country may be on the verge of a partial healing of this scar. If the government adopts the exciting proposals put forward by Renzo Piano for the rehabilitation of the old opera house site into an open-air theatre, retaining the old features of the bombed ruins enclosed within a modern, transparent structure, the Maltese people would not only preserve the memory of that once-glorious building but also enjoy - at least for part of the year - the benefits it offers as a theatre. Within the context of the need finally to regenerate what was once the beginning of Valletta's finest street, there can be no doubt that the main thrust of Mr Piano's proposals should be implemented. There is now no turning back for the government but, especially, for Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi.

An interesting feature of the Piano plan "to keep the soul of the opera house" alive is the wish to add to the existing ruins through the re-construction of part of the building using old stones, columns and statuary that once belonged to the majestic opera house building.

When one sees photographs taken immediately after the Royal Opera House was bombed, it is remarkable how much of the old building survived. At a rough guess perhaps one third of the outer walls were left standing. What one can still see now at the entrance of Valletta is, of course, much less!

A catalogue of part of the stone-work of the old opera house and its location has, in fact, been compiled in an exercise conducted by the Grand Harbour Regeneration Corporation as part of the research support they have been giving to the Renzo Piano Building Workshop entrusted with the project.

The inventory includes busts and decorated key-stones, column bases and shafts and Corinthian capitals, which once graced the Royal Opera House and then dispersed in a variety of locations from San Anton to Msida, to Santa Lucia and the Marsa Sports Ground.

One hesitates to enquire too closely how stone features that had been stored presumably for safe-keeping with a view to their possible future use came to be scattered around Malta in this way.

What is worrying, however, is that what has been found constitutes only the tip of the ice-berg. "Unless the pieces held in private hands are revealed, they remain untraceable and the list cannot be exhaustive," said the Ministry for Investments.

What is needed now is a concerted effort to complete the cataloguing process and, more importantly, to persuade individuals who in one way or another have acquired such pieces to return them in readiness for their rehabilitation at the new site.

On the assumption that the acquisition of such items was probably ultra vires, it would seem appropriate that an amnesty should be declared in order to encourage people to come forward. It is in the public interest and would be an act of public-spiritedness that this stone-work, which is a part of the nation's cultural heritage, should be returned whence it came. Private owners should be encouraged to respond in a spirit of cooperation.

  • Google Bookmarks Del.icio.us Facebook Blogger YahooMyWeb Digg Reddit Stumbleupon
  • email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Comments

Antoine Vella (on 17/7/09)
D. Vella Did you know that the old theatre space is already being used for cultural events in summer and winter? There were events last Christmas for example. The site has been used for years, since the time that Francis Zammit Dimech was minister responsible for culture. Carnival is held in the open every February. Often it's windy and sometimes it rains but nobody ever said that it should be held indoors. Argotti Gardens is also used for cultural events: the latest one being a few days ago. For many years the MLP organised annual cultural events which lasted several days there. You can ask anyone who ever attended: they were never disrupted by planes, pigeons or petards. Does Argotti Garden have a roof? Yes it does actually: the sky.
D Vella (on 17/7/09)
Exactly which part of the year 'to enjoy' the open air Theatre do you have in mind?. Most of Autumn and all of winter is out. A couple of weeks in Spring maybe?. Summer with it's festa's in and out of Valletta and airplanes and football matches and activities on the fosos just outside and it's bus terminus within hearing range is not on... so all in all , two or three weeks in spring with inter sprinkled day's in Summer. Seriously,why are you going all out to support the unsupportable?
g.portelli (on 17/7/09)
"This was a devastating blow that has left a physical and psychological scar on the face of Valletta from which it has still not recovered"

The ruins are still a psychological scar because the building as it was is still within the living memory of thousands. Hence there is still a public nursing of real loss. Attempts as made to compare these ruins to any other are therefore irrelevant.The Maltese are still in mourning for their Theatre. Prof.Piano's proposal is almost cynical. He gives us a parliament which is really designed as a theatre and the theatre which remains a ruin. I think he is making a witty comment about the Maltese but more so is making a subversive rally for Culture. I think he really meant I can show you what you can do with the space, and it's All about theatre. Now that is genius!


NB
I sincerely doubt whether that theatre will be much use roofless, yesterday evening Valletta was definitely not conducive to open air theatre, music performace etc.. the petards were strong and consistent. Is Prof. Piano around to factor in the noise and the potential success of his proposed design?
Joseph Bartolo (on 17/7/09)
I would suggest that the new national arts auditorium as one can put it, have a retracktable roof, so that it can be used throughout the year not only in the summer season.
Alfred Falzon (on 17/7/09)
So the old opera house will be used as an open theatre which means that sound and lighting equipment as well as the seats installed will have to be removed, transported and stored somewhere else until the next season. Has anyone calculated the annual cost of such recurrent works?
Galea. L (on 17/7/09)
The Government should give a time limit within which all remains in private hands must be returned and then anyone caught with any piece of the ruins would incur a very hefty fine and possibly imprisonment. The remains are owned by the PUBLIC not private persons.

Poll

Was the budget good for Malta?

  • yes
  • no
  • don't know
  • don't care


View results

Fun Stuff


Play Sudoku