Berlusconi accuses rivals over woman's death
Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi said Eluana Englaro, who died in the middle of a debate about her right to die after 17 years in coma, had been killed and the head of state was among those responsible.
"Eluana did not die a natural death, she was killed," the conservative premier told Libero newspaper, blaming Italy's leftist President Giorgio Napolitano for rejecting an emergency decree that would have forced doctors to resume feeding her.
"Napolitano made a serious mistake," another paper quoted Berlusconi as saying. The premier lamented that the bill he then sent to parliament to stop Eluana's nutrition from being suspended "did not make it in time".
Englaro, who had been in a coma since a car crash in 1992, was "the only citizen to be condemned to death", he said.
But the leftist newspaper l'Unita had a black front page with the words "In Pace" -- "in peace".
The flag flew at half-mast over the Senate, which had been discussing Berlusconi's bill to stop the 38-year-old woman's father and doctors from suspending her nutrition when she passed away suddenly at a clinic in the northern town of Udine.
Doctors stopped feeding her on Friday at her family's request in line with a ruling by Italy's top court. Berlusconi said this amounted to euthanasia, which is illegal in Italy.
Conservatives and the centre left accused each other of seeking political capital from the case, which has riveted Italy and angered the Vatican. Some opposition figures see Catholic cardinals' influence behind Berlusconi's outspoken stance.
"I hope God will help us to heal this wound," the head of the Italian bishops' conference, Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco, told local TV, adding that the country "needs a just law, for the good of our society, to avoid events like this being repeated".
"INHUMAN"
"You cannot let someone die of hunger and thirst," said Berlusconi's ally Umberto Bossi, head of the Northern League. "It is something primitive, inhuman, unacceptable."
Englaro has been called "Italy's Terri Schiavo", the American woman in a vegetative state who was allowed to die in 2005 after a long legal fight.
Catholic activists who had been opposed to stopping feeding Englaro said the courts should order her body sequestered for an autopsy and a judicial investigation, asking why she died so quickly when she had been expected to survive for several weeks.
"Something very strange has happened," said Gianluigi Gigli, head of the "For Eluana" anti-euthanasia group, late yesterday.
Outside the Udine clinic where she died people prayed and sang through the night, holding candles.
Her father, who battled through the courts for 10 years to have her feeding tube disconnected, saying it was her wish not to be kept alive artificially, simply said: "I just want to be alone."
Some ordinary Italians, who have followed the case closely for years through the media, expressed relief that Englaro had died, whatever side they took in the ethical debate.
"I am happy her suffering is over, after reaching a point where there was just nothing to be done," said Rome resident Laura Lichieri. "She deserved a peaceful death."
5 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
katie micallef
Feb 11th 2009, 04:16
why is it that everyone is so scared of death? Would you honestly want to watch someone you love die in an excrutiating way instead of letting them go before they suffer? A terminal illness is just that - terminal..the patient will die - the question is just when and in how much pain. Existing in a vegative state isn't living, to be alive is more than just a heart beat - its also cognition, awareness of life. It's just an extension of the inevitable death and extra suffering for relatives who aren't able to move on.
Why is quantity of life so much more important than quality?
Many of you say she was denied the right to live..but didnt she also have the right to die?
PM Camilleri
Feb 10th 2009, 18:48
@H.Calleja
Fully agree with what you wrote. Let us now hope that such a law is passed soon through the Italian parliament in order to prevent such an incident from ever happening again. Euthanasia must be banned. Period. With regards to Eluana's sudden death, I think her death was quickened by the private clinic. Would be interesting to see what the Italian government will do regarding this over the coming days and weeks.
H.Calleja
Feb 10th 2009, 16:41
Frankly I think everyone concerned made a mistake. If Berlusconi wanted the law to be enacted before the sad death took place,he should have started the Parlament debate much before it was too late.He knows pretty well that in three days such an enactment would not have passed both Houses. On the other hand I think that the Udine clinic should be punished for openly defying the Italian law on euthanasia. Eluana's father is also at fault because he has been instigating what eventually happened yesterday.
PM Camilleri
Feb 10th 2009, 16:34
This was not a question of living or dieing in peace but a question of defending the fifth commandment, Thou Shall Not Kill. Eluana was denied the right to live and has worryingly opened to door to euthanasia in Italy.
leonardo vince
Feb 10th 2009, 13:28
Politicians not only do not let you live in peace, but neither die in peace!