Joe Borg eyes second term in Brussels
Cachia Caruana, Busuttil also in the running
Joe Borg. Photo: Darrin Zammit Lupi
EU Commissioner Joe Borg has admitted that he would like to serve a second term, though permanent representative Richard Cachia Caruana and MEP Simon Busuttil are also in the running for the post.
With 10 months to go to the end of the current European Commission's term, the race for the seat of Malta's next European Commissioner has begun.
When contacted, Dr Borg told The Sunday Times: "I will be very happy to continue serving as Commissioner in the next Commission."
However, he admitted that he had had a change of heart on the issue in recent months after initially feeling that one term was enough.
"It is true that at first I was not interested in a second term. However, now that I have got to know the workings of the Commission very well - and think that I've done a good job - I wouldn't really mind serving for more years if the Prime Minister gives me the opportunity."
Sources said the Prime Minister would take a decision on the issue after the European Parliament elections in June.
Both Mr Cachia Caruana and Dr Busuttil declined to comment on the issue.
Despite never having contested an election, Mr Cachia Caruana is widely considered to have played an instrumental part in the Nationalist Party's successes both in the Fenech Adami and Gonzi eras.
Apart from being chief negotiator during Malta's intense accession process to the EU, Mr Cachia Caruana served for 15 years as the top aide of Eddie Fenech Adami. He was then appointed as Malta's first Permanent Representative to the EU and attends the weekly Cabinet meetings at Castille.
Dr Busuttil, considered by the Prime Minister to be one of his party's best assets - so much so that he approached him to become the PN's general secretary after the last general election, though he was rebuffed - is also in the race.
A lawyer by profession and considered to be an EU expert, the former head of the Malta-EU Information Centre, who this year turns 40, is also a formidable vote puller for the Nationalist Party. Dr Busuttil had polled a record 59,000 votes in the MEP elections in 2004.
A senior official within the Office of the Prime Minister told The Sunday Times that Dr Gonzi's choice would be difficult.
"The three candidates are all very good. Dr Borg has done a good job in Brussels and a second term could get Malta a better portfolio in the next Commission. At the same time, Mr Cachia Caruana is an excellent administrator and he will surely be a tough fighter for Malta's interests. Dr Busuttil has made an exceptional impression as an MEP despite coming from a small member state."
On the other hand, the sources said that the Prime Minister will also take into consideration other factors.
"While Mr Cachia Caruana was instrumental in Dr Gonzi's success at the last election and the Prime Minister must feel indebted to him, he will not be easily replaced in Brussels. On the other hand, Dr Busuttil might still be considered as too young, although other commissioners in their early forties have been appointed before. Dr Busuttil is also seen as a vote puller and still has a great future in the Nationalist ranks."
Back in 2003, when the first Maltese EU Commissioner was to be appointed, Prime Minister Eddie Fenech Adami made his choice from a list of three candidates: Dr Borg, Mr Cachia Caruana and then Finance Minister John Dalli.
The sources said that this time round, the Prime Minister's decision will also be influenced by what happens in the European Parliament elections. If the centre-left obtains a majority in the next EP, as is expected, it is almost certain that the current President of the European Commission Jose Manuel Barroso will be given a second mandate. This will put Dr Borg in a better position to be re-appointed, although Mr Cachia Caruana and Dr Busuttil made a name in the EU circles over the past five years.
Manoeuvres on an EU level have already started with some serving commissioners expressing their willingness to extend their term.
An EU Commissioner is appointed for a five-year term by the European Commission President following individual recommendations by the governments of the 27 member states. The post comes with a financial package of €220,000 per year, among other benefits.
7 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Matthew Gatt
Jan 28th 2009, 14:45
@Marco Ellul
While you are right in pointing out that the Commission is the body representative of the EU's interests, as distinct from those of the individual Member States, the reality is that the identity of the nation state remains the predominant one in the real world of politics. Whether the Commissioner is Maltese or French is important in so far as it influences his upbringing, his ideals, his culture, etc... For simplicity let's call this his frame-of-mind: and ultimately the work of any individual (especially a Commissioner) is a direct product of his or her frame-of-mind!!
So for goodness sake, let's not confine our ideas to textbook babble. The real world is what counts. And in the real world the nationality of the Commissioner makes a difference!!
Oscar Cassar
Jan 18th 2009, 11:24
Having a financial package of €220,000 per year, among other benefits I am not surprised that Dr Borg wouldn't really mind of serving for more years as a Commissioner in the next Commission. This although I acknowledge that he had probably done a good job as Malta’s first Commissioner.
I expect that our PM will keep in line with the promise of introducing new blood within the Governments cabinet of Ministers. In the previous legislation there were valid politicians that had a good performance as Ministers and they are now as back benchers in Parliament. Therefore the post of EC Commissioner must be taken as another opportunity to rejuvenate our government while giving support to more energy and new ideas within our political structures.
Joseph Mizzi
Jan 18th 2009, 10:38
H Mifsud - well said. Except that now we're playing with a chair less: George Abela grabbed his and he won't let go!
Joseph Agius
Jan 18th 2009, 10:19
@marco ellul
good point!
Marco Ellul
Jan 18th 2009, 10:11
'At the same time, Mr Cachia Caruana is an excellent administrator and he will surely be a tough fighter for Malta's interests.'
Whoever said these words, has no idea how the European Union, particularly the Commission, works. The Commissioners are there for the common good of the Union, and they do not represent the interests of the countries they come from. Or, rather, they should not.
Lorna Grech
Jan 18th 2009, 10:08
I think that Dr Borg has had his chance and he did a good job. But now it's time for someone else.
H. Mifsud
Jan 18th 2009, 09:54
Nothing new except that we keep on getting better at 'musical chairs'!