• email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Malta praised over progress against racism

Malta has made a leap forward in combating racism and discrimination, according to a new report published in Europe.

Analysing the progress made by EU member states in the field last year, the usually critical European Network Against Racism (ENAR) acknowledged that Malta has significantly improved its situation although it still considers the island's detention policy with regards to illegal immigrants as being too tough.

"2007 was marked with remarkable legislative developments in the field of anti-discrimination, migration and integration. The non-employment aspects of the race equality directive were transposed through a number of legal notices enhancing the protection against racism in law," the report states.

"The National Commission for the Promotion of Equality was appointed race equality body (for the non-employment aspects) while the shift of the burden of proof was further strengthened. The Broadcasting Authority enforced requirements as to the standards and practice on the promotion of racial equality imposing a duty on broadcasters to be proactive in promoting racial equality in their programming."

According to ENAR, during 2007, the communities most vulnerable to racism and religious discrimination in Malta included "irregular migrants", Muslims, as well as organisations working with asylum seekers. However, although mentioning some minor problems, such as difficulty in employment or in the housing rental market, the report didn't report any serious incidents.

The report also mentions improvements in the office of the refugee commission and the setting up of the Organisation for the Integration and Welfare of Asylum Seekers. It highlights various positive initiatives such as an anti-racism campaign in schools coordinated by the Malta Football Association and teacher training offered by Amnesty International Malta together with the Ministry of Education.

At the same time, the European Network reiterated its criticism of the conditions in detention centres used for asylum seekers. The lack of adequate data collection was highlighted as an issue of horizontal concern.

As a follow up, ENAR is now recommending that Malta should draw up, adopt and implement a National Action Plan Against Racism providing a strategic direction to combat discrimination while developing a more inclusive, intercultural society based on a commitment to inclusion by design, not as an add-on or afterthought.

It is also recommending that detention of asylum seekers is "to be restricted to the absolute minimum". Currently asylum seekers can be detained for up to 18 month.

ENAR has seven member organisations in Malta including the Jesuit Refugee Centre, the Peace Lab and the Third World Group.

  • Google Bookmarks Del.icio.us Facebook Blogger YahooMyWeb Digg Reddit Stumbleupon
  • email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Comments

lgalea (on 2/12/08)
Joe Vella
You cannot classify those who speak against the invasion of their own country by aliens as racists.
It is only if they commit a crime that is based on race that you can called them racist

But speaking against illegal migration is not being racist, but being NATIONALIST.

As regards ENAR, they know what to do with their report.
Michelle Dali (on 2/12/08)
It is good to read that discrimination and racism are being tackled. However, the recommendation that the detention of asylum seekers should be " restricted to the absolute minimum" is wrong, in my opinion. Illegal immigrants come to the country illegally and with no documentation. They very often refuse to divulge their country of origin. This means there is no way of knowing if they have a criminal record. Is it right that these people should be let loose on the streets, possibly putting the law abiding citizen at risk? If they were genuine they would cooperate with the authorities and would not need to be held in detention for long. The fact is many of them are not genuine refugees. Some of them turn to crime as we read so often in the newspapers. When this is the case they should not be discriminated against, but forcefully repatriated without delay.
Charles Sammut (on 2/12/08)
Racism was unheard of before Malta experienced a massive influx of illegal immigrants.

So if the EU and its busybodies want to eradicate racism they should do something firm and positive to stop and reverse illegal immigration.

As it is, guilt is being placed on our doorstep where it definitely does not belong. But at least the EU and the way it "operates" is now clear to everyone.

Denis Catania (on 2/12/08)
@Zap Branagan: Per capita, no one has more illegals than Malta. Per square miles no one has more illegals than Malta. How many EU countries has volunteered to take some of the illegals, since the signing of the immigration pact on Oct 16th 2008??? We don't need to refurbish any centers, we can give them the freedom to seek asylum in another state. Which is what they really want.
louise vella (on 2/12/08)
@ Zap Branagan
"Look at the uproar over the new parliament in Republic Square. Can you imagine the uproar if money was actually spent building or refurbishing a proper immigrant centre?"

Uproar? According to TheTimes online poll, 52 % are in favour, 43 % against the proposed new building.

But the government has never had the guts to ask the people of Malta: "who is in favour and who is against illegal immigrants?"

Does anyone care to guess? Is the government following the democratic will of the people of Malta?
Denis Catania (on 2/12/08)
@Joe Vella: The answer to your question is YES. A racist should go to jail and serve a full sentence, if he commited a racial crime. This is why I beleive the people who are thinking about spending 60-80 million Euros on the City gate project. Should be charged with a crime. The crime of spending 60-80 million Euro for a nonsence project. When you have 4,000 illegals living in a pre WW2 prison and tents. Tents Mr.Vella, NOT modulars with heating and plumbing. So who should we charge first on racial bias, Lawrence, Carm Mifsud one of the Tonio's. Tell me Mr.Vella who should be charged from the government??? Mr.Vella would you be proud to tell an African Canadian that your country of origin is keeping Africans in tents in 2008???
Zap Branagan (on 2/12/08)
@Denis Catania:
"When the illegals are unwanted by the all Northern States."
Do you have any idea the percentage of foreign-born nationals in the northern countries? It far exceeds Malta's. Malta is relatively homogenous compared to most of Europe.

"But the countries of the EU want to keep the illegals trapped in Malta, in a sad and inhumane way"
I rather think that the EU says that illegal immigrants are to be confined to the country through which they've entered the EU. The "sad and inhumane" way they are kept in Malta is due to Malta itself. Look at the uproar over the new parliament in Republic Square. Can you imagine the uproar if money was actually spent building or refurbishing a proper immigrant centre?
David Seychell (on 2/12/08)
"European Network AGAINST RACISM (ENAR) acknowledged that Malta has significantly improved its situation although it still considers the island's detention policy with regards to illegal immigrants as being too tough."

The detention policy of illegal immigrants has nothing to do with racism. All illegal boat people receive the same treatment whether they are black or white.
Raymond Sammut (on 2/12/08)
This is reminiscent of the social engineering and brainwashing under Socialist dictatorships of the seventies. The Maltese people owe nothing to something like the ENAR, and must never be afraid to speak out and to remind politicians of their obligations towards Malta and the Maltese.

The Maltese government is not "being too tough" with illegal immigrants. The Maltese government is failing to keep illegal immigrants in detention and to return them to their home country as is required by immigration laws.
Denis Catania (on 2/12/08)
An EU organization telling us how to treat illegals. When the illegals are unwanted by the all Northern States. The best solution is too give them freedom of movement within the EU. But the countries of the EU want to keep the illegals trapped in Malta, in a sad and inhumane way.To make matters worse, LawrencePN is afraid to stand up to the EU. For what ever reason, he's afraid to STAND up to the EU. Maybe he should try doing it sitting down. But he must do something.
louise vella (on 2/12/08)
ENAR’s report, first circulated on 10 October, is signed by Jean-Pierre Gauci of ENAR. Besides the 3 organisations mentioned, ENAR Malta includes Somali Voluntary Organization, Koperazzjoni Internazzjonali Malta (KOPIN), People for Change Foundation (PfC) and Solidarity and Overseas Service (SOS Malta). Their membership is not publicly known and there is probably a lot of duplication. It is not known to which of these organisations Gauci belongs.

The report says: “in employment, manifestations included difficulty in finding regular and stable employment and poorer working terms and conditions”. The report does not say how an illegal immigrant can obtain legal employment. It does not acknowledge that the only reason employers hire illegal immigrants is precisely because they can give them poorer wages and conditions. Above all, it ignores the threat by employers that as economic recession sets in and unemployment rises, they will sack Maltese workers and hire instead immigrants under poorer (and illegal) conditions.

“The lack of adequate data collection was highlighted as an issue of horizontal concern.” More statistics and more information are a way for an NGO to obtain funds – more statistics, more reports, more funds, more statistics …

Joe Vella (on 2/12/08)
@ l Galea

So should Racist People be locked and kept under lock and key until they repent.
lgalea (on 2/12/08)
Muzzling the people when they speak against ILLEGAL immigrants.

As far as detention is concerned it should not be reduced, but extended to the whole period that the illegal immigrants are in Malta.

That is the only way to make sure that the message gets across that they will not be allowed to roam in Malta and will be kept under lock and key until they are repatriated.

Poll

Do you agree with the European Court decision on the removal of Crucifixes from classrooms?

  • yes
  • no
  • don't know
  • don't care


View results

Fun Stuff


Play Sudoku