Updated: Muscat slams 'irresponsible' government over the tariffs
Dr Muscat is 11 years late - PN
(Adds PN reaction)
Opposition leader Joseph Muscat in a radio “message to the nation” this afternoon strongly condemned the government for its decision to raise the water and electricity rates and announced a national non-political protest manifestation.
Dr Muscat said the government’s decision would mean a very heavy burden on thousands of Maltese families and many companies.
The government, he said, could not have chosen a worst time to impose the new tariffs, given the international financial and economic crises. While overseas governments were intervening to help their peoples and their economies, the opposite was happening in Malta.
This was a time when the government should be helping families, not asking the families to help the government.
Dr Muscat said the new tariffs would cause a serious deterioration of living standards for many families.
The new measures were in stark contrast to the promises made just a few months ago before the general election.
The government, Dr Muscat said was irresponsibly ignoring the deteriorating situation in the employment sector, where workers had been sacked and others were working reduced hours..
That the government was introducing the new rates retroactively also went against all principles of economic stability and undermined the country’s credibility in the eyes of investors. Indeed, the Prime Minister during their recent televised debate had indicated that the new rates would not be backdated to October 1. Dr Gonzi therefore, either did not know what was happening, or was not telling the truth.
Dr Muscat said the government was proving that it did not believe in social dialogue and had turned consultation into a farce.
Indeed, the Prime Minister’s absence in the past, crucial, days was noticeable. He had not shoulder his duty to ensure that the new tariffs gave proper consideration to the interests of families and businesses. Instead, Infrastructure Minister Austin Gatt had taken over and “with typical arrogance” rolled over everything and imposed his decision on he social partners.
Now that the government was pushing the economy and the people into a crisis, it needed to ensure in its Budget on Monday repaired the damage. Rather than continuing to discourage the people, the government needed to instil confidence in the people and the economy.
Dr Muscat said that in deciding to hold the national manifestation, the MLP would be acting in the same way as all the people did in democratic countries, most recently in Italy last week. This would be a manifestation of the people for which all were invited, Dr Muscat said.
The Nationalist Party in an reaction to Dr Muscat’s address said the Labour leader was 11 years late, and what he said today should have been said when the Labour government raised the power tariffs even though the oil price was only $12 per barrel.
At the time, the PN said, Dr Muscat had written in the press and spoken on the broadcasting media to defend the Labour government’s actions.
The PN said the Labour government never had talks with anyone before then Finance Minister Leo Brincat presented his budget on November 5, 1997. Indeed, Mr Brincat in his speech had not had the decency to spell out the tariffs and asked the House to take them as read.
At the time, Dr Muscat had said that was a “courageous budget”. He had also said it was far-sighted, fair, and "a reflection of a serious government”.
In contrast, the PN said, oil prices were now high and the situation was very unstable. The new tariffs had been preceded by broad consultation and changes had been made, where possible,to safeguard jobs.
The new tariffs also included assistance to those who needed it most, the party said.
104 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
n mamo
Nov 9th 2008, 21:42
I am not a pn supporter anymore anymore, ax dahak bija,...
deb bugeja
Nov 3rd 2008, 18:50
@ James Hamilton
I agree with you that Dr Muscat won t be doing wonders if he is a Prime Minister. Global warning is there and we have face it.
However what I dont stand is that before election which is only 8 months ago, the PN lied to us and promised us so much ' too good to be true promises' and now the true colours are out.
What I cant stand as well is that the all the governments tries to burden us average earning workers with taxes which we have to pay for the deficit while those professional people who declare very much less than they earn pay less taxes. that is justly unfair.
J cassar castaldi
Nov 2nd 2008, 17:23
The PN is eleven years late and now enemalta is bankrupt and it us us who have to get Gonzi and enemalta out of trouble with our hard earned cash
P.Schembri
Oct 31st 2008, 17:46
@G.Gatt. I don't like to visit the past not because I'm ashamed of my past, but proud of it. You should be ashamed of your party's past. For every law, social or not, that Labour passed, the PN always voted against it Am not going to recite, or I'll end filling up this newspaper, but I"m sure you know what I'm talking about. About strikes. Are you suffering from amnesia or what? Did you forget that between 1977-1981, there were record strikes, when the then new PN leader declared that it's time to topple the legally elected labour government with over 12,000 votes? And then started a series of strikes to destabilise the government of the day? Or you have forgotten? Do you remember, all those industrial actions, protests, demonstrations and what not? If not I can describe them to you one by one. And of course, one must not forget the bombings. So check your history before you say something. Labour is proud of its past, unlike the PN.
george cutajar
Oct 31st 2008, 16:42
Yes quoting the MLP of their past because they are very ashmed of it.
Usually the GWU takes the lead to call a national strike and not the MLP. but now Because the GWU is toothless { bla snien . dak lijghejdulu kelb li jinbah ma jikdiex ) because gone are the 8 th army { dockyard Members ) gone are the memberr of sea Malta. gone are
port workers, gone are the member of cargo handling. gone are members of air Malta.
U ghalekk bil fors il-MLP kellu issejjah ghal protesta Hu. ghal ma ghandux aktar forcina
wara minn istahba.U ghal kull haga ta xejn that dan il-gvern kienet issejjah strajk
P.Schembri
Oct 31st 2008, 11:20
@S.Castalletti. Don't you see that the PN thrives on hate and lies? You should know by now. They managed to destroy Alfred Sant's reputation, there' s a hate campaign still going against Dom Mintoff, and another one against all that is Labour. This has been going on since the 60's and looks like there is no sign of it abating. As for the lies that are being perpetrated, well I leave that to your judgement. Demonising and character assassination is the order of the day in Maltese politics.
Saviour Castelletti
Oct 30th 2008, 20:18
I don't know why all this hatred for Joseph Muscat. And no one from the PN apologists are mentioning anything about Lawrence Gonzi's lie on Xarabank that an agreement had already been reached with the social partners that the tariffs would not be backdated.
Yes we have to speak out to safeguard our way of living. The people voted for a party that is repeating LIES. We can't live this lie any more. !!!!!!
P.Schembri
Oct 30th 2008, 19:48
@Martinelli & PN sympathisers. Will you please stop telling us what happened 10 years ago. /we're in 2008 not 1997. The PN has been in government these last 10 yeas, so it's not the MLP's fault for the deficiencies and inefficiencies in Enemalta. It is the MLP's fault of the government's mistakes. So why should I Joe Public pay for the Government's mistakes. And what call on the MLP for proposals? Doesn't the government have his own advisers and authorities to help him face and solve the problems he himself created? So please, don't give us all the crap of what happened 10 years ago. Anyhow. Dr. Sant tried to mend the inefficiencies and debts of Enemalta, but PN for political mileage was against it. Now it's the same story all over again, but this time there is an economic crisis on the horizon.
J Cassar Castaldi
Oct 30th 2008, 16:46
Gonzi's word means nothing. On TV gonzi stated that he had already agreed with the social partner on the mcesd that the tariffs will not be back dated. It seems he had not, but just gave us a false statement just to give us a good impression of him. Ho does half the nation believe this guy?
It is either he has not told the truth on TV or else he has taken the MCESD members for a ride? Maybe the Mcesd could enlighten the nation on this.
J Cassar Castaldi
Oct 30th 2008, 16:28
These tariffs are robbery in broad daylight. KPMG were commissioned to compile the report on which the tariffs are based on 04/04/2008. This report was presented by Auistin Gatt on 01/10/2008 at which time the price of oil was USD100. Obviously the report was passed on to Austin Gatt well before. The price ofd oil duing this period varied between USD110 and USD146. So all these calculations were based on a much higher price of oil than it is today. Why were these not revised accordingly? Are we buying oil at such higher prices and if yes who was responsible for this decision? Shouldn't this person whose mistake is costing us millions of euro be made to resign and possible face proceeding as is done in other countries when stupied decissions are taken?
To add insult to injury the minister also assures us that if the price of oil increases by 15% than we will get another increase.
What a frace. Can you belive this? We are being charged rates based on an average oil price of around USD125 and if current oil prices around USD70 increase by 15% to say USD 81 we will get another price increase.
NOEL DARMANIN
Oct 30th 2008, 16:26
MR TWANNY BORG,I THINK YOU ARE NOT LIVING IN MALTA.YOU DONT REALLY KNOW WHAT IS THE PEOPLE SAYING.OR YOU ONE OF THOSE WHO DONT PAY TAXES,DONT PAY FOR ELECTRICITY,DONT GO TO SUPERMARKETS TO BUY EVERYDAY NEEDS??? MR BORG,THE PROMISES OF YOUR LEADER WERE NOT THESE FOR SURE.
V.Micallef
Oct 30th 2008, 12:48
@ .M.Dingli, Etienne Pavia, Tancred Schembri, P. Scicluna, Michael Sant, M. Farrugia, Mike Magri, Paul Vella Cretien, Rodrick Abdilla, A.Abela, D.Falzon, Isabelle Aquilina, Jimmy Borg, Keith Davis, Roberto Vella, James Hamilton, A.Muscat Inglott, John Debattista and MARCO de CARLO (a real intellectual): I salute you, ladies and gentleman, I reckon you are the young and brave people that Dr Joseph Muscat needs around him. This is the moment for you to join his WINNING GENERATION. Go on, don't miss the occasion. Your participation, not only for the forthcoming momentous NATIONAL PROTEST, but for the eventful struggle for the survival of democracy in our Islands, will be crucial and beneficial.
Joe Galea
Oct 30th 2008, 11:26
For all those always quoting the past, the MLP's raise in tariffs 11 years ago came when there was a political turmoil and the government of that time was fed witht he wrong data from it's own employees since everyone retained his/her place. I remember very well the nationalists at work and everywhere saying "Il-hmar taghkom u nirkbuh/insuquh ahna". Moreover, when the govt. saw that he was making a huge mistake retreated from that proposal and wasn't stubborn and dictatorial as this Government. So please stop playing the game, that my wrong is right because you made that wrong too. Two wrongs don't make one right. Please, try to mature and atop trying to fight a lost battle. You don't impress anyone.
Joe Galea
Oct 30th 2008, 11:21
@Joseph Agius and likewise: You are those who live in the past and you say try to discredit JM because in the past he defended a Labour tariff increase. JM admitted that he wasn't always right on certain decisions, what's wrong with that. Is there anyone out there who is perfect? So with your reasoning we should stay home be happy to pay those hefty killing tariffs your government has imposed on us all, especially in times where there is a world crisis. Come on grow up and try to think outside of your box!!!
Finally we have a politician who is progressive and who is starting to wake up the country from a cumbersome sleep it's been during the last 20 years. This is the right move to do. We should stand together and show this arrogant dictatorial government that we had enough of his bad decisions, one after the other. We ahve the right to protest and I invite everyone to attend. It's our future which is at stake. Well done JM for such a proposal. Everyone was waiting for a move in this direction. Wakey wakey Malta!!
G .Mangion
Oct 30th 2008, 09:43
Is this your only Alternativa Sur kap joseph ?
Calling for a Manistifation at streets , wont solve nothing !
We all know that . why dont you tell the Gov't an - Alternative ? oh you dont have ehh !
It is you the Irresponsile One
EX !!!
joe borg
Oct 30th 2008, 08:52
All of you asking for solutions, how about the government lowers its tax on fuel? Everytime the price of fuel goes up the government increases its income from fuel taxes. Some 300 percent of the original cost. Do the math. No subsidies there just outright daylight robbery. Solutions indeed. Or will you defend your beloved thieving government at all costs? And don't take it I belong to the other side either. Just lost my blinkers somewhere along the way.
J Martinelli
Oct 30th 2008, 00:07
Keith Davis et al
Please don't keep boring us with the NP governments squandering Lm500 million which Labour left fil-kaxxa ta Malta.
When did you last have water delivered by water tanker?
When was your electricity out two or more times a week for hours on end?
When did you make a telephone call only for someone to cut in listening on your conversation, or worse, cut you off?
When did an NP government tell you what to buy and when you buy it because it adopted bulk buying?
When did you ask your relatives living overseas to bring you toothpaste, chocolate and other toiletries because they were banned from coming in?
When did a NP government prohibit you from importing household items while its ministers (and friends of) were bringing in shiploads of furniture from Italy?
When did an NP government requisition private homes and turn them into Nationalist Party clubs?
When did a Nationalist government take over national properties (eg il-Macina) for its own party's private use?
When did any key ministers in a Nationalist government find it necessary to resign because of conflict with the leader?
List is too long 200 word limit is too short!
J. Abela
Oct 29th 2008, 23:29
What a a shame!. Burden on hotels, industries and consumers!. Look around wherever you go and one can notice decrease in tourism. Soon we'll end up like ghost country. Well lets keep this at the side, when we Maltese shall stand up for our rights and persuade our government that we're not dummies?.
Wait and see and people will forget all about this just a couple of months prior to the coming election.
Mark Spiteri
Oct 29th 2008, 23:16
@Angelo Micallef
Christian Democracy is what I believe in.
Seems you have a better suggestion and solution for the crisis the country is currently in.
So lets hear it.
David Scicluna
Oct 29th 2008, 22:24
@ Twanny Borg
"Gonzi stay strong and don't let chickens dictate the way! VIVA PN FOREVER!"
Well done eh! A really persuasive argument.
Mike Magri
Oct 29th 2008, 21:59
@ Joe Vella.
Joe, i did not say that Government Borrowings and Budget Deficits, technically speaking, are the same. I only said that wether any monies due, are derived from any or both systems above, it just have to be paid out to someone anyway, as per following very abridged example.
(a)..Amounts due from Government Borrowings - Local and Foreign........... X Million Euro
(b)..Dues from accumulated Budgeted works on finished infrastructural
projects, like schools, roads etc.., supply of medicines, machinery and
various other goods and services, Not Yet Paid...................................................Y Million LM
(c).. Interests due on (a) above.................................................................................Z Million LM
TOTAL NATIONAL DEBTS.... XYZ Million LM
= 1.8 BILLION LM
or 4.193 BILLION Euro
That`s the whole story Joe..
=
Edwin Formosa
Oct 29th 2008, 21:54
JOSEPH MUSCAT ON THE SAME SUBJECT; """Dr Muscat said the government’s decision would mean a very heavy burden on thousands of Maltese families and many companies """
""" At the time, Dr Muscat had said that was a “courageous budget”. He had also said it was far-sighted, fair, and "a reflection of a serious government”."""
Joseph E Briffa
Oct 29th 2008, 21:49
May I ask for somebody to come up with a comparison of an average annual household bill for electricity consumption of 15 units a day ( roughly 5 500 units p.a.) and 100 m^3 of water per annum according to (1) the existing rates + 95% surcharge and (2) the new rates? Many thanks
Ethelbert Schembri
Oct 29th 2008, 21:38
Go on Leader we are after you 100 %
Jerome Attard
Oct 29th 2008, 20:41
My thoughts go out to all those workers who have had their jobs terminated or reduced to a four-day week. Though politically, this is the right time to introduce austere measures, socially and morally, it is utterly insensitive and will only contribute to more job cuts and hardships to our families. Just when we were all led to believe that the economy was doing very well? Politicians are becoming professional liars.
Muscat. P
Oct 29th 2008, 20:36
@Joe Vella
Yeh, those who borrow prosper, but after LM 2000 million of debt where is the beef let alone the fat?
Joseoh Dalli
Oct 29th 2008, 19:34
Safrattant, il-Gvern ta' Austin, ghadu ma indikax figura wahda zbaljata fl-analizi tal-Partiti Laburista u ghax huma bbazzati, fuq il-prezentezzjoni li l-Gvern wera MCESD.
Carl Brincat
Oct 29th 2008, 19:21
You know about the three wise monkeys and their representation of see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil? One can look at Gonzi, Gatt and Fenech as the reincarnation of these into the three dumb monkeys (with due respect). With their impositions these ppl are not seeing any evil in what they are saying nor do they want to hear what others want to say in this regards. Today these are the front persons of a demotivated lot who have no ideas about how to go about and solve the problems, the main part of which are the result of their own bad decisions. So all they can do is blame it on us and the world, and hope to get away with it. How about they take their share of the blame and resign, to make way for others?
Joe Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 19:07
@ M. Vella
My apology to Zammit S. the following was meant to be addessed to M. Vella.
Contrary to what you say, An Opposition duty is not only to criticise, but is duty bound to offer solutions/alternatives to the Government and demonstrate that it is ready to Govern.
An opposition that only criticises is destined to be just that - an opposition for life and not a Government in waiting
Mario Bonnici
Oct 29th 2008, 19:06
"The PN said that oil prices now are high...".!!!!
They were very high in July, and diesel and petrol prices went up. Now, oil prices went down but diesel and petrol prices remained the same.
Can our beloved government please explain.
Joe Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 19:04
@ Mike Magri
It is indeed relevant. Ask any economist. Government borrowing and Budget Deficits are seas apart
Muscat P.
Mention one person who had prospered in life that didn't had to borrow, or one Country that didn't progressed who didn't have to accure debt from time to time. The underlying factor Mr. Muscat is where the Government is borrowing from.
Please save me do not mentionanyone who accumillated his/her wealth by inheritence.
D Attard
Oct 29th 2008, 18:56
Apart from the fact that the PN reaction is as backward looking as can be and it DOES NOT JUSTIFY the stubborn decisions the Govt has taken, esp. with regards to the fact that the tariffs are retroactive..................................................11 YEARS AGO THE MLP HAD RETREATED THE TARIFFS
J. Buhagiar
Oct 29th 2008, 18:43
The GattPN Government (As the Par idejn sodi has made a vanishing act) is always talking about the 30,000 who get subsidized tariffs, but seriously does anyone here know anyone from these 30,000 households
And while I am at I have another question how many households are there in Malta????
As for the apologists for the GattPN government, they really had a busy day today, if you follow all the blogs regarding the issue of the price hikes, the same names keep popping up and at all times of the day.
meditate gente meditate
Muscat.P
Oct 29th 2008, 18:43
@Joe Vella
Government's debt are uncollected taxes, in the economist's jargon. How is that for good and viable administration. We borrow anew ( new bonds) after we have paid the old debt , and from then its a never ending story.
Mike Magri
Oct 29th 2008, 18:37
@ Joe Vella... It is irrelevant of how the government debts are classified.. Whether Budget Deficits and or Maltese People`s loans, at the end of the day, it all has to be Accounted for, paid back... The full 1.8 Billion Maltese Lira + accumulated interests.. Joe.. And that`s A LOT of money for such a tiny Island...!!!!
Joe Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 18:35
@ Zammit S
Contrary to what you say, An Opposition duty is not only to criticise, but is duty bound to offer solutions/alternatives to the Government and demonstrate that it is ready to Govern.
An opposition that only criticise is destined to be just that - an opposition for life and not a Government in waiting.
Joe Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 18:27
@ Zammit S
You write; "Politics for me is about putting priorities first. At the moment the new water and electricity tariffs are not a priority."
I cannot agree more with the first part of your statement. However, I strongly disagee with the second part that deals with th tariffs part. What is at heart here is the present situation of the Government subsidising the poor and the reach equally with the present system in place and at the same time rewardin also those who waste.
Mr. Zammit, I submit to you that the faster the Government do away with the subsidies, the sooner the Government can truly address the Priorities that you spoke of. This albatross of subsidaries should be taken off the backs of the taxpayers immediately. Only then the Government can truly focus on helping those who are really in need in our society and invest in expanding the economic pie in our country; which in turn all of us can benefit from.
joseph debatista
Oct 29th 2008, 18:27
I am not a labour supporter but definitely I am not a pn supporter anymore . These five years were extra for pn administration and they were given to us by mistake . Now it is showing in the way that our government is ruling the country
patrick mifsud
Oct 29th 2008, 18:26
welcome to Malta the island of experts-prophets and grumbling people. when you address the nation please address the people that you want to take political advantage of them. instead of addressing the nation give us the proposals you said that you worked out with a team of experts. bla bla bla
Joe Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 18:16
@ V. Fenech
The real Zombie is you my friend for taking all of us as one.
Talking about dishonesty; You should look into the mirror.
You stated that "All the papers today focused onto the tariffs while in-Nazzjon was discussing Tony Abela. What a miserable and sour-tasting party!! "
Here is the digest taken from The Times itself; "In-Nazzjon says the new power tariffs are designed to safeguard jobs as they include new assistance for the 26 biggest employers. It also reports that MLP deputy leader Toni Abela was insulted at an MLP committee meeting in Gzira.'
It is quite clear who is being miserable, and still have a sour taste in thier mouths.
Joe Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 18:04
@ Mike Magri
Malta's debt is not the problem. The debt that occured by the PN is with the Maltese individuals and instituations. Just as recent as last week a stock issue of 50 million Euro was over subscribed before it hit the road. This has been the trend that every time a PN led government issue a bond/stock issue is oversubscribed each time. This is the best certificate of trust that the Maltese People and Instituations can give to the Government of the day.
I say Malta's deb't is no problem because no capital in form of interest payments is send oversees. The interest is paid to Maltese and stays here which means more money in the maltese hands thus more purchasing power.
The problem, in as far as debt, is another form of debt which is called Budget deficits. This Government is well on its' way to elimate the defecit in the forseen future. Budget defecits means that one is living beyond its' means. Once the deficit is eliminated Malta will be trulyon its' way to economic expansion never seen before.
Twanny Borg
Oct 29th 2008, 18:04
Gonzi stay strong and don't let chickens dictate the way! VIVA PN FOREVER!
muscat inglott
Oct 29th 2008, 18:02
always keep in mind what was the slogan few months ago
FLIMKIEN KOLLOX POSSIBLI
now go to the MCESD group and ask them if it is the same today ?
Keith Davis
Oct 29th 2008, 18:01
Can we all stop politicizing this issue as usual. Here in Malta its either blue or red! The problem is the issue and how people tackle the same issue!
I am ready to pay in full for what I consume.
I am not ready to have subsidised bills to make good for those with pools and also the industry!
LESS TARIFFS MEANS MORE TAXES = SO PEOPLE MAKE YOUR CHOICE !
ray muscat
Oct 29th 2008, 17:58
these are not tariffs . These are dictatorship acts
this goverment is acting like stalin used to do . Shame on Dr Gonzi
l Galea
Oct 29th 2008, 17:50
S Bezzina
Prices not changed over the last 30 years?
Were you lviing in Malta?
Keith Davis
The Nationalist Governments have squandered Lm500 million left in Malta's coffer by the Labour Governments and put the country into more than €4,000 million debt. So the Gonzipn Government is in panic to balance the budget because the eu is breathing down Gonzi's neck and its the people who are being made to suffer. It is the MINORITY Gonzipn Government and it's apologists who are being arrogant when they are doing the opposite of what other governments around the world are doing.
Karl Abela
Arrogance is being shown by the MINORITY Gonzipn Government and those who defend it. It is the Gonzipn Government's responsibility to find the solutions, not the Opposition or the people.
Pierre Agius
Its the arrogant MINORITY Gonzipn Government and its apologists who want it hobla u tredda. If Gonzipn had and semblance of decency it would call for fresh elections.
John Debattista
Oct 29th 2008, 17:47
Lets forget which party we are with,, We should all take to the street and show the Goverment were the Power OF THE PEOPLE is and stand against the New Tariffs, Don't FORGET every body is going to be effected especially the Middle Class and below.
Mike Magri
Oct 29th 2008, 17:46
@ Keith Davis.... Jahasra Keith........
WHO ON EARTH WAS IN GOVERNMENT FOR THE LAST 21 YEARS, (Less Labour`s 18 months).........!!!!????!!!????
WHO LEFT OUR MONSTROUS AND UNSUSTAINABLE DEBTS GROW SO HUGE, YEAR IN, YEAR OUT, SO MUCH SO, THAT THEY ARE COMPLETELY OUT OF HANDS NOW...!!??!!??
WHO DIDN`T GIVE A HOOT ABOUT ACCOUNTABILITY, AND `PROTECTED` THOSE WHO SHOULD HAVE BEEN SACKED DURING THE LAST 10 YEARS IN GOVERNMENT...!!??!!??
GonziPN`S GOVERNMENT AND THEIR POLITICAL APPOINTEES IN PARASTATAL COMPANIES..... THAT`S WHOM....!!!
MISMANAGEMENT OF THE CITIZEN`S TAXES GALORE.....THAT`S WHAT, KEITH...
THUS.. WHY SHOULD OUR POCKETS ALWAYS HAVE TO MAKE GOOD FOR OUR UNACCOUNTABLE POLITICAL GAFFES AND `OUT OF DATE` POLITICIANS, CHAIRPERSONS, DIRECTORS ETC....ETC....!!!???!!!???
No.. No.. My Friends... This time WE MUST ACT... Enough is Enough...
albert leone ganado
Oct 29th 2008, 17:42
It is quite amusing to note that the way the story board is evolving is just a replay of what happened before in 1996 when rightly and justly Dr Sant raised the utilities tariff. The only difference is that the actors have changed. For PN protestors in 1996 read MLP protestors in 2008.
To be fair the GWU did raise reservations at that time. It is perhaps time that the UHM did the same now to achieve perfect irrational symmetry.
If we want to rise above partisan political stances it t is time people asked who has been paying the subsidies to the tune of over 100 million million for the past three years. It was certainly not Drs Gatt or Fenech but it was us the middleclass the long suffering group who bears the brunt of all taxpaying.
Perhaps with these new tariffs business will start paying its long overdue dues and hopefully the same applies to someme of those 30000 who claim unjustified support.
V Fenech
Oct 29th 2008, 17:18
Welcome to the world of the blue zombies where the surviving ones still choose to try and defend the government when causing such a catastrophe himself. Shame on you!
I thought I heard Dr.Gonzi say that he would leave the tariffs for next year. Eventually these nationalists’ die-hards can't understand that we're in a very sensitive situation. Unfortunately the government want to fix the holes it caused into our economy from our taxes. Who created subsidies in the first place and now has transferred all the burden of hotels and industries onto restaurants and other SME's???
This is the PN's problems and it has to fix it, now matter how they try to shift their burden onto others. All the papers today focused onto the tariffs while in-Nazzjon was discussing Tony Abela. What a miserable and sour-tasting party!!
Marco De Carlo
Oct 29th 2008, 17:15
The most effective way to restrict democracy is to transfer decision-making from the public arena to unaccountable institutions: kings and princes, priestly castes, military juntas, party dictatorships, or modern corporations.
m. farrugia
Oct 29th 2008, 17:13
At such a difficult moment, we should all be concerned about the wellbeing of the country and not of the political party we last voted for.
Although subsidies are not healthy for any economy and taxpayers, the govt has surely not tackled the tariffs issue and the current economic crisis in the best possible way at such a delicate moment. For example, to address tourism problem, the govt, instead of tackling the accessibility issue (weekly flights have been reduced by at least 20 flights a week)has said that it will allocate more marketing funds to MTA.
However, the country, as the rest of the world, is in a very serious situation and this is surely no time for creating more uncertainty such as stopping the country for another 3 months to call a fresh election, as we will soon end up all unemployed. It is probably even too premature for JM to govern, and the country will probably be faced with another crisis.
It is good that now finally we seem to have a strong opposition leader and he and the social partners should keep up the pressure on the govt to act responsibly in face of the current crisis.
Zammit S
Oct 29th 2008, 17:08
Like all the other people in the country I felt extremely shocked when I heard the new water and electricity tariffs. It's a true fact the oil prices are instable and that the economic situation around the world is not helping the present Governemnt, however the latter cannot always pretend to fix up inefficiencies by putting heavy burdens on the families. Families are already experiencing a lot of hardships because of the always rising cost of living. This together with the new tariffs will definately be a mortal blow of our country's economy. The Government seriously needs to think about alternative ways in the upcoming budget to help families and workers. One of them could be a wage increase!!! However I doubt this could really happen!!!
Politics for me is about putting priorities first. At the moment the new water and electricity tariffs are not a priority. There are many other areas that need an immediate and serious intervention. One of them is surely Education. The Government, instead of wasting time on these new tariffs, should have tried to address the multicultural issues present in education and the ever decreasing number of graduated teachers who are entering the private sector.
R Spagnol
Oct 29th 2008, 17:03
The PN has missed an important fact in their reaction - that the price of oil has came down to somewhere between 65 and 70 dollars. Comments like those by E Gatt and Angelo Micallef are very worrying since they show us that their party is controlled by two leaders/ prime ministers. Don't you even know that Austin Gatt promised that if the price of oil falls below 85 dollars, the surcharge rates would be revised??
Don't you know that Lawrence G on Xarabank promised that the new tariffs will not be backdated from the 1st October???
And do you pretend that the Labour party will come out with solutions when nobody has an indication of what has caused all this failure in the Enemalta performances. The Nationalists' party has implemented the capping formulations himself and now the government is U-turning back on our side against the subsidies. And no matter how much you go back to the past, these tariffs could in no way be related to the alterations in the w&e bills in the times of both Sant and Fenech Adami!
Rodnick Abdilla
Oct 29th 2008, 17:02
States are not moral agents, people are, and can impose moral standards on powerful institutions.
A.Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 16:53
It is not the Opposition's job to come up with ideas. Why have people voted PN in Govt then, to remain cicci-beqqi? The Opposition does not have the resources or funds to act as a Govt. The Opposition's role is to monitor the Govt's performance and not to shoulder the responsibility that has been vested to those in power.
Dominic Chircop
Oct 29th 2008, 16:49
What a crazy island !
An arrogant and unfeeling government, a non-existent opposition, and lower living standards for all.
Perhaps those modern day Savonarolas who hide in the PN and MLP may suggest a prayer of solace.
Attard C
Oct 29th 2008, 16:47
as the adage goes "Li tizra tahsad". pity that mhux minn xarrbu qed jieklu l-bakkaljaw .
S Bezzina
Oct 29th 2008, 16:38
Mr Muscat has been calling for progressive politics but yet he resorts to the old way of calling whatever the PN does as black.
We should be honest with ourselves and accept reality. The prices of water and electricity have not changed in Malta for over 30 years. This means we are paying for calculations made on payroll, expenses, oil and all other costs bourne by Enemalta those days. No wonder why Government has to cough up millions every year to make up for the shortfall.
Taking into consideration oil price alone, at only $50 a barrel it is still 5 times more than it was 10 years ago when we were paying the same tariffs. Are the new rates 5 times what they were?? I don't think so because with the figures being mentioned, we are at a little more than double.
Being progressive would have been saying that it is time to actually change the rates and be realistic and counter this increase with a stimulus package come budget day. Feel free to criticise the level of the increase but not the priciple Mr.Muscat.
We want real progressive politics and not politicians taking advantage of sensitive issues.
marsh c
Oct 29th 2008, 16:37
"@Karl Abela - What do you expect from a serious leader of opposition to just sit down and let the governement roll on everybody. Well done Joseph. We are behind you 100% in this. And please do it soon. The sooner the better!!!!
marsh c
Oct 29th 2008, 16:34
@E Gatt - I think it's your GONZI who must come with the solutions as you voted for his strong pair of hands. And By The way Joseph Muscat did make a suggestion. He said to help the economy these tariffs must be put on hold. The same suggestion came from ALL the members of MCESD. Other countries are using their reserve funds to help the economy. Where is our reserve fund ? Obviously the answer is there isn't any, because although we sold all our jewels we spent every penny. (L-aqwa li l-Finanzi fis-Sod)!!! People Wake Up It's time to fight for your rights!
E. Pavia
Oct 29th 2008, 16:26
Why do we always think of the past instead of building on the good of the present, and learn from the wrong doings of the past? When will we learn? Unfortunately politics in Malta go only 2 ways as most of the people are afraid to change their vote. If in my opinion this government deserve my vote, I will vote in favour, if things change, I will change as well! Both parties in parliament do mistakes and things right. Let's not always critisize our opponent party whoever you voted for. Obviously the parties are gonna critisize each other no matter what as that's politics but we as a nation who voted should say the truth and if something is obviously wrong, let's not say it is good and vice versa!
I agree with P.Scicluna's comments.
reading your comments today I can realise why we are in a mess;
1. Because we always have to compare the past, we never give concrete solution for the future
2. The way you are justifying the Government no wonder they just roll over us. Some gives the impression that what ever they do , you are always pleased.
Roberto Vella
Oct 29th 2008, 16:25
PN is in a state of panic or else it is outright lying. Are the new tariffs necessary as a result of the increase in oil prices? Is it because we have a worsening economic situation at a global level? Is it because enemalta is hugely inefficient and these inefficiencies have to be recouped? All of the above excuses have been used interchangeably at one time or another depending on what suits best. When oil was high then it was because of oil prices but when this decreased the reason was changed to inefficiences. However it is difficult to make people pay for enemalta's (and by inference government's) inefficiencies so it is now the economic situation's fault. Yet this was known way beforehand - remember Dr Gonzi warning of dark clouds ahead? - yet despite the clouds he promised not to revise the tariffs
Joseph Muscat 11 years late - so what. since when do two wrongs make a right?
Joseph Muscat 11 years late - and who has spent the last 20 odd years or so supposedly implementing restructuring and reforms and what not at enemalta? what does a PN government have to show for it?
A Abela
Oct 29th 2008, 16:13
I will join the protest even though not a MLP supporter. We can not let this arrogant government roll over the people like this. What do they take us for. All social partners should unite and protest against these tarrifs, we simply can't afford them.
Tony Bonello
Oct 29th 2008, 16:11
I totally agree with Dr.Joseph Muscat, apart for all those Nationalist out there I'm an ex Nationalist canvaser, party official also was Director of Santa Lucia club. This goverement is arrogant so lets hit the streets peacefully.
isabelle aquilina
Oct 29th 2008, 16:11
That is what the labour needs to do to show solidarity, its force and a common voice for all of us in the street. We need to show that we are there for the people by protesting harshly as these people think that this time they can contioue with their hidden agenda and bypassing everyone, withour anyone expected to talk or argue about. Well most of ushave had enough of these attitudes as the PN are now acting dictatariorily and not as democractes as we all are supposed to be. We cannot remain in the past but we must place are actions on what we are facing now and the future. There is no use crying over spilled milk but place our knowledge and skills into action for everyone to benefit and increase their purchasing power and not deplete resources/
D Falzon
Oct 29th 2008, 16:10
This is just another case of typical arrogance that one can expect from our beloved Nationalist Party. 'Heaven on earth' BEFORE election, 'Kanna A1' AFTER election. As long as the Maltese people are happy........
Jimmy Borg
Oct 29th 2008, 16:10
I'm not a labourite but on this particular issue I support every word said by Dr Muscat. Today it feels shameful to be a Nationalist and it's useless to bring out press releases talking about 10 years ago. MLP's mistake at that time resulted in a change of Government. I won't be surprised if the same thing happens again this time. Unfortunately the arrogance being shown by my party in Government is annoying party members as well.
Joe Borg
Oct 29th 2008, 16:08
Mr Muscat has been calling for progressive politics but yet he resorts to the old way of calling whatever the PN does as black.
We should be honest with ourselves and accept reality. The prices of water and electricity have not changed in Malta for over 30 years. This means we are paying for calculations made on payroll, expenses, oil and all other costs bourne by Enemalta those days. No wonder why Government has to cough up millions every year to make up for the shortfall.
Taking into consideration oil price alone, at only $50 a barrel it is still 5 times more than it was 10 years ago when we were paying the same tariffs. Are the new rates 5 times what they were?? I don't think so because with the figures being mentioned, we are at a little more than double.
Being progressive would have been saying that it is time to actually change the rates and be realistic and counter this increase with a stimulus package come budget day. Feel free to criticise the level of the increase but not the priciple Mr.Muscat.
We want real progressive politics and not politicians taking advantage of sensitive issues.
James Hamilton
Oct 29th 2008, 16:05
Good grief, the way that people go on about, "What would Joseph Muscat do"? Or "Why hasn't the MLP presented an alternative".
I would like to think that he wouldn't be stupid enough to raise prices at this uncertain time when the World is heading for recession.
The unions have also pleaded to the government not to raise the rates at this particular time, especially when factories are already laying off some of their work force.
Will hotels be next due to poor winter bookings?
As the government seems to have decided to impose the higher tariffs I suggest that the government wait at least six months and see where the country is heading financially before implementing the higher rates.
Keith Davis
Oct 29th 2008, 16:04
Who on earth would want an increase in taxes? But are we prepared to move on or do we not care at all to let our national debts grow?
For every Eur1 of fuel that Enemalta pays we can not pretend to even pay less then that?
Would you open a shop and sell less then cost?!
Solutions people, not grumbling please!
Rodnick Abdilla
Oct 29th 2008, 16:01
Get up, stand up, stand up for your rights
Rodnick Abdilla
Oct 29th 2008, 16:01
So long as we have enough people in this country willing to fight for their rights, we'll be called a democracy.
tancred schembri
Oct 29th 2008, 15:55
Jekk dr muscat qed jigdeb mela l ishab socjali kollha qed jagmhlu l istess ghax bhalissa kulhadd vuci wahda .
Konna nghidu ghall alfred sant u spiccajna aghar minnhu . jien nisthi nghid li kont nazzjonalist .
jien ghandi familja ta 3 min nies u gibtuni dahri mall hajt . Spiccajt nahdem 4 tijiem fil gimgha u l mara bla xoghol . Thank you Dr Gonzi talli 4 xhur ghidtli mod u issa taghmel mod iehor
Mike Magri
Oct 29th 2008, 15:49
@ J. Borg.."How is it that we always have to cite the past.... Its the future we are interested in.."
Exactly Mr. Borg... It is ONLY because the GonziPN government, has NO sound arguments for its Present Utilities Gaffe, and consequently, NO convincing arguments for a better Future...
Let Us ALL Be Counted In This Hour Of NEED, and participate in this National and non-political Protest, as otherwise WE ARE ALL GONNA GET CRASHED Guys...!!!!!
paul vella critien
Oct 29th 2008, 15:47
GOVERNMENT is irresponsible TO INCREASE TARIFFS TO THESE LEVEL, IT SEEMS, IT HAS LOST ITS SOCIAL responsibilities TOWARDS THE FAMILY.
BY THE WAY, IN WHICH PAGE WAS IT WRITTEN IN ITS ELECTORAL PROGRAMME THAT IT WAS INCREASING THE TARIFFS SIX MONTHS AFTER THE ELECTION, WHY DOES NOT THE GOVERNMENT HOLD RESPONSIBLE THOSE WHO TOOK BAD DECISIONS IN THE PAST? ACCOUNTABILITY PLEASE, AND SACK THEM? I TAUGHT WE HAD IL- FINANZI FIS SOD, B...L....T. WHO IS LYING OR TAKING PEOPLE FOR A RIDE,,,.
ARRIVEDERCI BANANA REPUBLIC,,,,,
IT SEEMS THAT THE PN HAS LOST ITS BOXLA,
g.c.forte
Oct 29th 2008, 15:46
How stupid you have to be to pretend that Joseph Muscat,the M.L.P. or any other entity comes up with the solutions of how to solve the problems of this government, when most of them were created by the bad management. With arrogance you will reach nowhere.
Maria Farrugia
Oct 29th 2008, 15:45
Just look at what's happening in Italy!
Students, lecturers, parents all in the street against the government. There are also right wing student organisations participating. That is what protesting means, uniting against a issues which affect everyone irrespective of political ideology.
I urge Labour to remain positive in putting forward proposals, and at the same time not keep back from joining the people in the streets.
A. Attard
Oct 29th 2008, 15:39
Good job Dr. MUSCAT! We will all be there! PN call fresh elections, you can't possibly tibqghu tafgu fuq kulhadd!
Michael Sant
Oct 29th 2008, 15:38
Well done Dr Muscat and I really like to see all the MCESD taking part and this is coming from a PN supporter....but now enough is enough arrogance. Why should we always hear about Dr Alfred Sant's years .... who cares ...we should look at the future. I was one of those at tal Barrani....Shall I keep voting PN for eternity for that??
N tabone
Oct 29th 2008, 15:33
@karl abela
"The arrogance shown by Muscat is unheard of, to put it politely. He is seeking to gain political mileage during such a sensitive period where the country wants solutions, not polemics. "
Are you serious? are you telling us that we cannot protest because we would be dubbed as arrogant! I cannot believe your cheek Karl! have you forgotten the university students protests when labour dared touching their stipends!? have you conveniently forgotten ppl with pots and pans on their heads protesting? I think arrogance is in your veins! This is not just a section of society that will suffer this is all Malta and Gozo that will suffer, wake up open your eyes or else i must assume that you do not pay bills!
P.Scicluna
Oct 29th 2008, 15:30
TO; ALL
reading your comments today I can realise why we are in a mess;
1. Because we always have to compare the past, we never give concrete solution for the futur
2. The way you are justifying the Goverment no wonder they just roll over us. Some gives the impression that what ever they do , you are always pleased. Grow up dont be fools.
I. M. Dingli
Oct 29th 2008, 15:27
@ E. Gatt / Keith Davis
As P. Schembri pointed out in his comment, MLP tried to solve the matter in 1997 but the opposition party at that time, lobbied in order to show MLP as being a monster and actually achieved its goal of overturning the government. The problem of inefficiencies had to be tackled at that time and not in 2008.
This is exactly on the same plane as the statistics issued in September 2008 for the Government expenditure in 2006 which gave proof by facts that a lot of money was unaccounted for. Unfortunately this report came a bit too late for rectification to be made.
Phil Press
Oct 29th 2008, 15:23
What amazes me is, we do not receive a yearly bill. So how can the charges be based on what you may or not use a year ?. Are the bills based on the lower tariffs or the higher, if the higher, do you get a refund, including the interest, you would have made, if the money was in the bank. How can an estimate be issued, Is it based on a guess to how many occupants, in a property, during a certain period. Surely for this to work, you should receive an annual bill, after another. census.
You cannot expect people to give away money on guess work.
P.muscat
Oct 29th 2008, 15:00
@ E gatt.
Considering the multitude of experts, consultants, boards of all sorts, paid by the taxpayer, is there a need for proposals and solutions from the opposition?
P.Schembri
Oct 29th 2008, 14:58
@All PN Apologists. To defend your Party in Government you always look back to the past. "Il-Passat mhux mera tal-futur". When Labour tried to reform the w&e tariffs, there was no economic crisis looming ahead. Only the country's finances were bad. Ten years on, and we still have the same problem. If Labour was left to handle that problem then, we wouldn't be protesting now. That is political mileage by the PN. Not MLP mileage today. The people are in pain, but the Government is deaf to its cries. Only option to go in the streets and protest. MLP proposal to the Government was shot down with haughtiness. So why continuing asking the MLP for proposals? That's what I call arrogance.
ivan scicluna
Oct 29th 2008, 14:58
The more the PN continues to go back in years to criticise Joseph Muscat for what he did or what he said, the more it becomes irrelevant to Maltese society today. We are living in today's world with today's problems and what we have now are exhorbitant tariffs twice as much as the Labour Government was going to charge us 11 years ago and then it retreated from them. The MLP government was shown the door at that time, and by the arrogance of this government, it is risking the same. Joseph Muscat is just saying what all Maltese are saying: this is not what we heard just 8 months ago when all was roses. The people were taken for a ride. And also, all the world is behaving the other way round, trying to revamp the economy cycle by putting money in people's money to spend and invest. In our case, our government is tightening the screw on every household, being it lower, middle or higher class. One appeal to the PN: keep hammering on the past and you're doomed!!
R Grech
Oct 29th 2008, 14:57
Myself and many other hundreds will surely attend the manifestation eagerly awaiting MLPs realistic proposals for reduced utilities billing .... I mean, I cannot imagine MLP asking us to take the streets for the mere fun of it or to gain political mileage ... or is it so?
Angelo Micallef
Oct 29th 2008, 14:53
@ Mark Spiteri- Christian Democracy has nothing to do with this so do not drag Christian Democracy into this issue.
This whole protest by the Malta Labour Party is nothing more then a mere show by Joseph Muscat trying to turn what is essentially a very serious issue into a show to manifest his image as the defender of the people just like the good old days of the Labour Party I guess.
If Dr. Muscat really wants to protect the national interest perhaps he should come up with a solution since anyone can go scream in Valletta placards in hand but few actually suggest.
Keith Davis
Oct 29th 2008, 14:48
Dear Dr. Joseph Muscat people demand real solutions, not just grumbling and moaning.
I have read not MLP proposals whatsoever on how you would foot Enemalta's fuel costs.
Karl Abela
Oct 29th 2008, 14:43
The arrogance shown by Muscat is unheard of, to put it politely. He is seeking to gain political mileage during such a sensitive period where the country wants solutions, not polemics.
JOSEPH BORG
Oct 29th 2008, 14:42
PROSIT DR.MUSCAT LI SE TOHROG IL- POPOLU FIT-TOROQ. IN-NAZZJONALISTI MINN DEJJEM BEZGHU LI N-NIES IKUNU FIT-TOROQ. HU MINNHA TAT-TARZNA LI META HADNA XI HAGA DEJJEM HADNIJA MINN GO TOROQ. FL-AHHAR NIXTIEQEK TGHID LILL-MISSIEREK DUMINKU MINTOFF JEKK DR. GONZI HUX BLA KUXJENZA SOCJALI IZJED MILL-ONESTA TA DR ALFRED SANT.
Joseph Agius
Oct 29th 2008, 14:36
Unfortunately I still have the memory of Joseph Muscat defending harshly a labour party that had lost it's 'kuxjenza socjail'!.... so until I get demented I will judge this as a gimmick.
E. Anastasi
Oct 29th 2008, 14:33
I will definitely attend this protest manifestation. Government arrogance knows no limits and the only people capable of stopping it is us, the people. What MLP did 11 years ago might've been harsh. Indeed the entire country was put to a standstill by the then opposition and its supporters (including the GWU) even though during that time there wasn't the worst economic recession in the last 80 years.
We have the right to protest like you had 11 years ago and the Nationalist government is not going to take that right away from us as well.
C.Sapiano
Oct 29th 2008, 14:30
As always the MLP tries to jump on a bandwagon but its too late. Where was Joseph Muscat when Alfred Sant did the same apart from cutting the stipends?? AAh socialists !!!
A. Agius
Oct 29th 2008, 14:29
PN forgot to mention that the people forced a changed in government 10 years ago..... food for thought!!!
J.Borg
Oct 29th 2008, 14:19
What a place we live in......
How is it that we always have to cite the past........it's the future we are interested in.
I think that it's about time politicians we elect in parliament start thinking about our future and not our past.
That's gone and done with......we are not going to pay the hefty bills just by saying that we should have spoken on that date and so on.
Let's have politicians who think about our future....and who give us the best standard of living....
Grow up people
Pierre Agius
Oct 29th 2008, 14:15
Is it really irresponsible for the government to end subsidies on energy ? Shall we carry on wasting energy consumption, continue unchecked carbon emissions? I am really confused! literrally a case of 'hobbla u t-tredda'! Way to go!
Keith Davis
Oct 29th 2008, 14:08
Dr. Joseph Muscat in his speech once again failed to say how he would pay the difference in Enemalta's fuel cost bills.
Subsidising everyone's daily consumption utility charges is surely not the way forward for this country.
Its easy to grumble but it takes grey cells to find solutions eventhough these may be difficult.
Mark Spiteri
Oct 29th 2008, 14:07
I remember PN playing a song "You Have to Stand Up for your rights" during mass meetings.
This time its the whole country singing this song.
As an outright " Christian Democrat " I think Muscat's outcry is justified and relevant.
The Goverment has to realise that these "decisions" will have a massive negative impact on the whole country.
Manuel Micallef
Oct 29th 2008, 13:58
This is not a demostration only by MLP - but a MALTESE demostration to protest these tariffs when the oil price has gone down by 50% to under 70$ a barrel.
All are invited to attend
E Gatt
Oct 29th 2008, 13:51
Dr Muscat: You did not suggest an alternative - when you do, how much do you expect us taxpayers to fork out please?
The last proposal your party suggested earlier this year was to halve the surcharge and finally remove it: a measure that would have been disastrous from an environmental and fiscal perspective.
George Attard
Oct 29th 2008, 13:51
yes thats what i mean....power to the people.....but no politics plse. this is a national problem and if govt is adamant to introduce these tariffs, the people should be united and show their disapproval.
P.Schembri
Oct 29th 2008, 13:47
At last someone is taking over the situation. No more passiveness.