• email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Talking Point

Reversing summer follies

The clang of broken promises reverberating through the second Gonzi government's first months in office is now being accompanied by discriminatory decisions that know no rhyme or reason. The Sunday newspaper Maltatoday yesterday revealed that the Office of the Prime Minister has triggered a must-choose situation for three teachers in government schools who were also active in politics. Two of them were in the ranks of Azzjoni Nazzjonali. The third had the highest political profile. He is Alternattiva Demokratika's secretary general.

The first two, it was reported, bowed to the position put to them, and opted out of their political position. Alternattiva Demokratika's Victor Galea did not. He replied to the statement made to him that he could not continue to exercise his teaching profession - government teachers are precluded from holding any political post. He queried that position, citing discrimination. Bully for him. Discriminated against he definitely was.

In recent years and to this present day there have been teachers very openly active in either of the two main political parties. One could but should not mention names. The Office of the Prime Minister knows them well enough. I would not be surprised if among the hundreds of local councillors in office there are also several individuals who teach in government schools, and others of equal public service ranking. On top of that, not so long ago, the first Gonzi government finally recognised that public service employees elected to Parliament need not resign their government post, up to a very high level of grading.

One might say that the practice whereby government teachers and civil servants of similar or higher grading take open part in politics crept in by stealth.

Among the regulations governing civil servants there is the Public Service Management Code, which MaltaToday correctly described as being anachronistic.

It was put in place decades ago and bans any government employee up to scale 13 from political involvement.

I remember it well. When, then a clerk with the UK military establishments after some time as an emergency teacher, I started writing articles in the Labour media in the late 1950s, another Lino Spiteri, then a government teacher who had moved on to the Information Office, used to be called up to answer for "his" lapse. We used to have a good laugh about it together and reminded each other of it when we met in Canada many years later. But it was not funny for him at the time, until the mix-up was sorted out.

Over the years, various people with strong political beliefs who wanted to militate openly for their party pressed for the Public Service Code to be relaxed. Teachers would point out to the anomaly whereby University lecturers could take part in politics and even become members of Parliament and retain their University job.

It would be pointed out to the protesters that this was possible because University lecturers were not public officers. On the strength of that distinction there was also the anomaly that consultants working in public health who also held a lecturing position at the University could take an active part in politics and even become an MP, while continuing to work in government hospitals.

All that was yesterday - or so one was led to believe by the proliferation of public officers in active politics. I would like to think that the silly code muzzling public servants was resuscitated through some summer oversight. However, the folly came about, the decision should be reversed without delay. What matters is one's loyalty to one's job, and ability to keep politics strictly out of it.

  • Google Bookmarks Del.icio.us Facebook Blogger YahooMyWeb Digg Reddit Stumbleupon
  • email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Comments

Harry Vassallo (on 19/8/08)
This is one of those defining moments for thousands of people, a slip which shows the real face behind the icon. It reminds me of the PNs attempt to eliminate all senior citizens from the EU referendum. It was quickly abandoned and the PN claimed merit for its ability to repent, not quick enough to prevent thousands of people from realising that the Pn is capable of such things.
Well done Lino for picking up the cudgels
Richard Schranz (on 19/8/08)
The application of the relevant but anachronistic provision in what was previously known as the Estacode cannot be dismissed as being illegitimate but surely the case smacks of crass political discrimination. Everybody knows that many civil servants, in both part of the political spectrum, militate actively in political activities in one form or another. Victor, rest assured that you enjoy the respect and support of many fairminded citizens who appreciate your hard work and patriotism manifested in your unstinting efforts in trying to stop the degradation suffered continually by these islands, especially Gozo, all done without remuneration and at great personal sacrifice. Victor, vinceremo.
Astrid Vella (on 19/8/08)
Tragically this takes us back to the dark ages of Mintoffian rule when those who did not tow the Government line paid the price. We paid dearly, convinced that our defiance would eventually lead to a change of Government and a time when such things would never happen again.

How wrong we were! First we lost the sterling services of hard-working and scrupulously honest Carmel Cacopardo, and now Victor Galea comes into the line of fire, certainly undeserving of such treatment, not to mention the effect on his young family.

This latest move damages Government far more than it damages Victor; the fact that our authorities don't have the insight to realise this is yet another worrying aspect to this shameful, shameful case.

Alastair Farrugia (on 18/8/08)
I am disappointed, but not too surprised, to learn about the way in which MLP and PN officials are treated differently from those of AD and AN (even if I don't like AN's policies).
I certainly hope that Victor Galea can keep his political position and also his position as a teacher, as so many other people do without any problem.
Joseph Caruana (on 18/8/08)
Politics such as these are absurd in todays political arena. Even if in some way you would be able to limit the participation in the labour market to active participants in the democratic processes one would be hindering the creating, formationa nd actual participation of different political parties who can only allow politics move in a democratic fashion.

I aslo know Victor Galea a bit and I have no doubt over his integrity and exemplar behaviour. Which should be regarded as a virtue in the educational system. Keep up the struggle Victor you have all the right to fight for your position in society.

ADZ
S.Bonnici (on 18/8/08)
This is clear discrimination against Victor Galea. The fact that he is also employed in the civil service is a credit to its workforce, especially now that they are experiencing a brain drain and the king and his army are all aiming to land more lucrative occupations on the continent. Mr. Galea is Secretary-General of the Greens. With forty two seats, the European Greens have enough clout in the European Parliament to raise this issue and even vote against the EPP. He can also raise the issue with the EU Petitions Commissioner.

Malta needs to really grow up. I do not come from the same political background as Mr. Galea, but for this country to mature and progress from its current status of "wooden spoonists" in the European Union, with so many unenviable lasts, Dr. Gonzi should realise that with ploys such as this he is not winning brownie points, but may actually be discouraging hard-working civil servants, who still see a difference between serving the Maltese State and not his Party. AD cannot just play the hero anymore but they should name PN candidates, officials and party apparatchiks that are employed in the civil service. Self-pity gets you nowhere.




elsie coucom (on 18/8/08)
How ridiculous! Victor is definitely been discriminated against just because he belongs to the AD - does this mean that none of the thousands of civil servants are allowed to express their opinions in public? Why are they allowed to keep their jobs? Grow up Malta and keep fighting Victor.
Carmel Cacopardo (on 18/8/08)
Having been victim to political discrimination under a MIntoff led government, it appears 24 years later that governments never learn !

Discrimination is still considered an essential political tool.
Claire Bonello (on 18/8/08)
As rightly pointed out by Lino Spiteri, the question is not whether one holds a position within a political party but whether one does his job well- as Victor Galea undoubtedly does. Also, I do not see why this law is being applied only to Victor Galea and not to politicians within the PN/MLP
Ralph Cassar (on 18/8/08)
Probably Lawrence Gonzi will say that he knew nothing of this and that it was a mistake... it always is isn't it? Typical of the PN to use others to do its dirty work, then they claim innocence.
Michael Wetton (on 18/8/08)
Irregardless of whether you agree with his politics or not, I believe that everyone would agree that Victor Galea works extremely hard, and with true integrity, trying to improve the situation here in Gozo.

Surely the teaching profession needs people that are hard working and have such integrity, whatever their political persuasion may be.

I would echo the sentiments of the comments above. Is this not government discrimination and are we indeed living in 2008 or heading into an Orwellian totalitarian nightmare?
Mario Cardona (on 18/8/08)
I want to show my public support for Victor Galea, colleague and personal friend. I have worked with Victor for three whole years and we have discussed politics, agriculture, the environment, economics and culture during various encounters. This has only helped both of us, coming from different social and political backgrounds, to challenge our own beliefs and mature. And all our students benefitted from the process. On the other hand he has never took advantage of his position within state employment to gain political mileage for his party. I am in perfect consonance with what Lino Spiteri has written today. Victor, keep up the fight. All of us educators stand to gain from it.
Victor Fiorini (on 18/8/08)
Instead of thanking people like Victor Galea for his service to the political arena, we punish him! I wonder if this would have happened had Mr Galea been in the PN... hmm....

Victor Galea, don't give in!
Alexander Cortis (on 18/8/08)
This is unbelievable because it demonstrates clear discrimination against certain people whom the government think should be removed from their job. Would they be replaced with someone else who is in favour of the party in government? If, as Mr Lino Spiteri says, there are teachers who are active in politics to this day though I fail to uderstand why they cannot be named since Mr Galea has been named, the matter should be referred to the courts, ultimately, if need be, the ECJ.
I have a simpler solution. Change the law and make it consonant with true democracy or else retain it but prohibit other professions from becoming MP's; e.g. lawyers, notaries, etc. Perhaps architects too could be stopped from sitting in Parliament or on MEPA boards, to avoid any conflicts of interest.
Is this the transparency the voters were promised? Or has the Government started copying other sectors famous for being 'strong with the weak and weak with the strong'?!
Come on Gonzipn, give everyone a just deal and not this mockery of fairness. The country and the voters who elected you fully deserve it!
Gerald Fenech (on 18/8/08)
It is a shame if the Education Department had to lose Victor Galea's outstanding qualities. And the government talks about the EU and how much we have gained out of membership. This evidently does not apply to the good old sport of political terrorism (to borrow a quote from the former AD Chairperson) which is still alive and well in this country.
Lino DeBono (on 18/8/08)
I have the pleasure of knowing Mr Victor Galea as a very honest, integral, capable and intelligent person. I do support his stand for a very simple reason.

My question to Government is this : "Do the Government itself right at this very moment have Members Of Parliament in Government Employment?".

If it has MP's as indicated in my question, is it not being discriminatory with Mr Galea?
Francis Buhagiar (on 18/8/08)
The discrimination Gonzi government is creating amongst government employees make me feel as if I am living in George Orwell's book 1984.
Has Gonzipn any respect towards the Convention of Human rights.
Frans Buhagiar.
Victor Galea (on 18/8/08)
I thank Mr Lino Spiteri and like minded people who would like to start living in a 21st century Malta... not to mention that we were supposed to have become full EU members in 2004.

Poll

Will swine flu make you change some plans for the summer?

  • yes
  • no
  • don't know
  • don't care


View results

Fun Stuff


Play Sudoku