
Monday, 18th August 2008
Talking Point
Reversing summer follies
The clang of broken promises reverberating through the second Gonzi government's first months in office is now being accompanied by discriminatory decisions that know no rhyme or reason. The Sunday newspaper Maltatoday yesterday revealed that the Office of the Prime Minister has triggered a must-choose situation for three teachers in government schools who were also active in politics. Two of them were in the ranks of Azzjoni Nazzjonali. The third had the highest political profile. He is Alternattiva Demokratika's secretary general.
The first two, it was reported, bowed to the position put to them, and opted out of their political position. Alternattiva Demokratika's Victor Galea did not. He replied to the statement made to him that he could not continue to exercise his teaching profession - government teachers are precluded from holding any political post. He queried that position, citing discrimination. Bully for him. Discriminated against he definitely was.
In recent years and to this present day there have been teachers very openly active in either of the two main political parties. One could but should not mention names. The Office of the Prime Minister knows them well enough. I would not be surprised if among the hundreds of local councillors in office there are also several individuals who teach in government schools, and others of equal public service ranking. On top of that, not so long ago, the first Gonzi government finally recognised that public service employees elected to Parliament need not resign their government post, up to a very high level of grading.
One might say that the practice whereby government teachers and civil servants of similar or higher grading take open part in politics crept in by stealth.
Among the regulations governing civil servants there is the Public Service Management Code, which MaltaToday correctly described as being anachronistic.
It was put in place decades ago and bans any government employee up to scale 13 from political involvement.
I remember it well. When, then a clerk with the UK military establishments after some time as an emergency teacher, I started writing articles in the Labour media in the late 1950s, another Lino Spiteri, then a government teacher who had moved on to the Information Office, used to be called up to answer for "his" lapse. We used to have a good laugh about it together and reminded each other of it when we met in Canada many years later. But it was not funny for him at the time, until the mix-up was sorted out.
Over the years, various people with strong political beliefs who wanted to militate openly for their party pressed for the Public Service Code to be relaxed. Teachers would point out to the anomaly whereby University lecturers could take part in politics and even become members of Parliament and retain their University job.
It would be pointed out to the protesters that this was possible because University lecturers were not public officers. On the strength of that distinction there was also the anomaly that consultants working in public health who also held a lecturing position at the University could take an active part in politics and even become an MP, while continuing to work in government hospitals.
All that was yesterday - or so one was led to believe by the proliferation of public officers in active politics. I would like to think that the silly code muzzling public servants was resuscitated through some summer oversight. However, the folly came about, the decision should be reversed without delay. What matters is one's loyalty to one's job, and ability to keep politics strictly out of it.






RSS
Comments
Well done Lino for picking up the cudgels
How wrong we were! First we lost the sterling services of hard-working and scrupulously honest Carmel Cacopardo, and now Victor Galea comes into the line of fire, certainly undeserving of such treatment, not to mention the effect on his young family.
This latest move damages Government far more than it damages Victor; the fact that our authorities don't have the insight to realise this is yet another worrying aspect to this shameful, shameful case.
I certainly hope that Victor Galea can keep his political position and also his position as a teacher, as so many other people do without any problem.
I aslo know Victor Galea a bit and I have no doubt over his integrity and exemplar behaviour. Which should be regarded as a virtue in the educational system. Keep up the struggle Victor you have all the right to fight for your position in society.
ADZ
Malta needs to really grow up. I do not come from the same political background as Mr. Galea, but for this country to mature and progress from its current status of "wooden spoonists" in the European Union, with so many unenviable lasts, Dr. Gonzi should realise that with ploys such as this he is not winning brownie points, but may actually be discouraging hard-working civil servants, who still see a difference between serving the Maltese State and not his Party. AD cannot just play the hero anymore but they should name PN candidates, officials and party apparatchiks that are employed in the civil service. Self-pity gets you nowhere.
Discrimination is still considered an essential political tool.
Surely the teaching profession needs people that are hard working and have such integrity, whatever their political persuasion may be.
I would echo the sentiments of the comments above. Is this not government discrimination and are we indeed living in 2008 or heading into an Orwellian totalitarian nightmare?
Victor Galea, don't give in!
I have a simpler solution. Change the law and make it consonant with true democracy or else retain it but prohibit other professions from becoming MP's; e.g. lawyers, notaries, etc. Perhaps architects too could be stopped from sitting in Parliament or on MEPA boards, to avoid any conflicts of interest.
Is this the transparency the voters were promised? Or has the Government started copying other sectors famous for being 'strong with the weak and weak with the strong'?!
Come on Gonzipn, give everyone a just deal and not this mockery of fairness. The country and the voters who elected you fully deserve it!
My question to Government is this : "Do the Government itself right at this very moment have Members Of Parliament in Government Employment?".
If it has MP's as indicated in my question, is it not being discriminatory with Mr Galea?
Has Gonzipn any respect towards the Convention of Human rights.
Frans Buhagiar.