• email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Updated: Air Malta to allow blind girl to travel with guide dog

Catia Lima and Lee.

Air Malta is next week to review its policy on guide dogs on flights, but it will tomorrow allow Catia Lima, a blind 30-year-old Portuguese, to board a flight from Northern Italy to Malta with her guide dog Lee curled under her feet, an airline spokesman said.

The airline had originally intended to separate Catia from Lee, a five-year-old yellow Labrador. Lee was going to be carried in the aircraft's hold.

Roy Perry, press officer of the Malta Guide Dogs Foundation, told timesofmalta.com that despite an EU regulation on the carriage of assistance animals travelling by air, which came into effect last month, Air Malta had still not put into place operational procedures to allow this.

He thanked the airline for waiving the excess baggage charge that was to be applied and hoped that Air Malta would bring itself in line with the EU directive soon.

Brian Bartolo, Air Malta's general marketing manager told this portal that the directive quoted by Mr Perry was subject to national law, which said nothing on the matter. Therefore, the EU regulation was not binding on Malta.

Nonetheless, Air Malta acknowledged that this was a new reality and would be reviewing its operations to comply with the EU directive next week. In the meantime, it would be making an exception for Catia tomorrow.

Workers, Mr Bartolo said, would have to be trained and training was usually done in the winter.

He pointed out that the directive said that when a guide dog was travelling with a passenger, the airline had to be informed reasonably in advance and Ms Lima only booked her ticket on Wednesday.

Air Malta, he said, was all for collaborating with the Malta Guide Dogs Association, and had even assisted the organisation with five airline tickets for the purpose of training.

Mr Perry said that elsewhere in Europe Catia had been able to travel by air with Lee curled under her feet, in total comfort and safety.

He said the Malta Guide Dogs Foundation hoped that Catia’s stay in Malta would be a happy one and that she would be treated with respect and not discriminated against in any way. It was also hoped that she would be allowed access to all establishments, public transport and places of entertainment.

  • Google Bookmarks Del.icio.us Facebook Blogger YahooMyWeb Digg Reddit Stumbleupon
  • email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Comments

shaun camilleri (on 17/8/08)
To Mr K Cutajar. These dogs are well trained, you must have a phobia. These dogs are better than any human who once the plane is in the air start moving about all over the place especially when the plane happens to be full of Maltese and many others start their holyday by getting sloshed.

Good on you for seeing sense Air Malta managemet. The only concern I have is that the dog has to be curled under her feet on the plane. There is no space for our feet when there is no living being under our feet so how can they be comfortable?

The space bettween the seats is barely enough for one person as is the elbo space between people. I hope you give them a proper welcome and make sure they are seated comforably. Dogs are God's creatures too you know. Also make sure you have some food and water for the companion too do not be stingy; and a bowl.

Air Malta welcome to the modern age and I hope you stay in it.
Joseph Attard (on 17/8/08)
Well done to Mr Brian Bartolo and his team at Air Malta for taking a reality challenge. Its people like these that Malta needs in the face of many decisions that need to be taken everywhere and in every sector.

People that are not afraid of having the guts to change the future. People like Catia Lima should be provided with all the help that is required so that they move on in life. Air MAlta has taken the liberty to be ahead of the Local Government. Thumbs up again and a splendid job done, and as for those who might moan cause a dog could be brushing up their leg during their flight, could they please think for a moment and ask themselves, what if Catia was their daughter? Would they think the same way. Lets be human in all our doingsin life and respect others who have so many difficult obstacles to surmount in life. Lets make sure they have one obstacle less, and thats us !
Michael Tabone (on 16/8/08)
@TIMOTHY PACE:

Well Tim, although I totally agree with you not all those problems are the fault of the government. I'm not saying the government is to be excused that these problems are still around because they could provide the tools to fix some of the problems you mentioned.

But the main reason we have these problems (Illegal Hunting, parking on pavements, dumping raw sewage at sea, air pollution, sound and light pollution and animal rights!) is mainly because we are a country which lacks disciplin. Think about it, people still stop their cars in the middle of a two-way road blocking one side of the road creating a single lane two-way road and we have the wardens around to stop this. I mean watch this footage and tell me we are a disciplined country: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84-ABlKi3zo

Anyway I personally see this decision as something morally right. People may complain but guide dogs are well trained and disciplined. People will complain only because they want to.
Frank Borg (on 16/8/08)
This is great news. Guide dogs for the blind are harmless animals, they are well trained for any situation and no one should be afraid of them. This is something that Airmalta should have done years ago, but better late than never. Guide dogs for the blind gives a second chance in life to these unfortunate people and they should be allowed everywhere. Well done Malta Guide Dogs Foundation for the work you're doing. - Frank Borg - The Maltese National Canine Federation
Charlie Galea (on 16/8/08)
It has always been Airmalta's policy to allow blind people to travel with their guide dogs. It has always been the policy to carry Live animals in the Aircraft hold. The reason being that many of the fellow passengers , mostly of the type Mr Joseph Briffa represents, objected to sitting in a confined space with a 30 kg Labrador brushing their ankles .
I commend Mr Brian Bartolo and Airmalta for taking this decision , even at the risk that some individuals will try to make a happy story into a sick melodrama .

I am sure that Airmalta cabin crew will give, as they have done in the past 30 years, the usual high standard of care that these people need whilst flying.

TIMOTHY PACE-LUPI (on 16/8/08)
@ Karl Abela: if you only knew how wrong you are! I have actively organised many such petitions infact and always give a helping hand to any good cause that comes my way. I am very patriotic my self and would not let any one speak out against my country with out reason. Oh I have also worked with the local authorities and know the dificulties the public system face. Yet it still saddens me and many, even members of the public system when it takes the local media, public opinion and foreign intervention to bring our local ways in line with EU directive. Should it always have to go this way? Many such items which we debate endlessly are standard proceedures which no one would even dream of going against in other EU nations.
Dr. Noel Calleja (on 16/8/08)
Travelling with AirMalta was always safe from my side and very helpful too. I am an animal lover and for those who don't know me I am a dog lover too. Such dogs are harmless and are trained not to lose temperament and keep themeselves calm at all times. They are even trained how to deal with a situation when their 'Master@ is in need of help. For all of those who are afraid of any dog and will eb travellling, they have two options on that day: either just forget that there is a dog on board or don't fiddle around where Catia's seat is. Enjoy your flight!
Denis Catania (on 16/8/08)
@agrech: Anyone who has dog phobia, shouldn't be walking the streets of Malta. I'm afraid of dogs too, but common sense will tell you, these dogs are safe, and a beautiful gift to mankind.
apgrech (on 16/8/08)
@ Mark Zarb: Allergy is different from phobia. In your case, your girlfriend would have to ask if any animals will be travelling on that flight and she may have to choose another flight.
Alex Fenech (on 16/8/08)
Well done AirMalta for providing access to Catia and other people in similar conditions. Considering AirMalta know well before hand that they are going to carry a guide dog, i think they ought to consider informing passengers at check-in (including web check-in) about the dog's presence in order to adjust seating accordingly should a passenger allergic to dogs happens to be on the same flight. In order to respect passengers allergic to dog/fur, i think that AirMalta should limit one guide dog per flight.
Mark Zarb (on 16/8/08)
I appreciate the situation and do realise that AirMalta is doing an incredibly good thing here - but I don't agree with the comment that apgrech made: "...they have to do what people who have flying phobia do - deal with it. Such dogs are harmless and behave much better than some humans do."

My girlfriend is highly allergic to not only dogs, but fur and feathers in general, and we know many other people with the same condition. It's not something you just "get over"; the allergy starts by closing up her throat, clogging her sinuses, streaming tears down her face and making her unable to breathe. Usually she has to leave the room within five minutes, else the condition can get much worse.

Are you telling me that 14,000 feet above ground, this is something you can just "get over"?
gaffarena joseph (on 16/8/08)
Air Malta was very late in doing this.Other airlines have been doing what air malta done to day, many years ago.
But as usual, it have to be a foreign person to open their minds, but better late than never.
Kenneth Barry (on 16/8/08)
The policy of allowing guide dogs accompanying blind passengers on board aircraft is adopted by the majority of Airlines. Airlines have procedures in place for this type of special handling. Glad to hear that Air Malta will allow this blind girl to have her guide dog with her in the cabin. Maybe this could become a permanent policy and not an isolated case.
apgrech (on 16/8/08)
C Psaila said: "What will the passengers who suffer from dog phobia do?...suffer a disasterous trip."

Well they have to do what people who have flying phobia do - deal with it. Such dogs are harmless and behave much better than some humans do.

Air Malta won a medal of respect from most of us.
Denis Catania (on 15/8/08)
@Eric Psaila and Brian Bartolo Air Malta is a first class airline, and I can put them up with any airline I flew around the world. Although I haven't flown Air Malta in five years and don't read Maltese that well. The only thing I found that was wrong, is the flight magazine is only in English. I would like it in English and Maltese, like Alitalia's left side of the page in English and the right side in Italian or vise versa.If that was changed in the last five years, please except my apology. If not can we do something about it.
Thank you for allowing Ms Lima dog on board.
@Berys Said: A diamond is a girls best friend. Most girls who get diamonds are not teenagers anymore. I bet you used that statement a few times.I hear ladies say to each other YOU GO GIRL all the time. Maybe these are American lines.
Eric Psaila (on 15/8/08)
@ Joseph Briffa
Mr Briffa
Air Malta has been awake since 1975 when it started operating as our National Airline.
At that time everyone was against Air Malta and thought it would not make it.
Oh yes it did make it Mr Briffa but probably not thanks to people like you who seem to be still against Air Malta. Air Malta has opened many routes and operated flights at a loss to support Malta' tourism industry. Shame on you and people like you who keep trying to harm Air Malta's image. What else don't you like about Malta? Perhaps its language like many Maltese who are shy to speak our language. There are many things which you can write about to complain but certainly not Air Malta who has served its mission over the years. Well done Air Malta.
Joe Tabone-Adami (on 15/8/08)
Air Malta certainly did the right thing when it changed its decision in order that the girl be with her guide-dog on her flight to Malta. Over here, we may not be very aware of the paramount importance of such trained dogs for blind people. I was greatly impressed when, three years ago, I saw that one of my fellow cruise-passengers was accompanied by her guide-dog for the whole duration of our trip. This required much more than the dog simply curling up at his mistress's feet for a two-hour flight.

Tony Caruana (on 15/8/08)
Dogs on planes are dangerous no matter what Roy Perry or the EU Say. I will not travel on a plane with a dog on board.
Fabian Mizzi (on 15/8/08)
Well Done to Air Malta for taking such a decision despite today being a public holiday. In this case Air Malta has shown that unlike other airlines, it really has the passenger's welfare at heart. Well Done Mr. Bartolo and others involved in this story with a happy ending.
martin saliba (on 15/8/08)
With regard to the last paragraph of this article.

If her stay is a happy one or not would depend on something that no one knows as obviosly her stay has not even started.

Do you have to be blind to be treated with respect?
Do you have to be blind to not be discriminated against?
Us there a reason why she would not be allowed access to an establishment , public transport or places of entertainment?

These types of comments tend to sugest that other blind people who have visited Malta were mistreated.

Journalists should be careful what they print and not report something that dosn't make sense or that can harm, say our tourist industry, just for the sake of filling a page with usless words.


Kenneth Cutajar (on 15/8/08)
@ C. Gatt
As regards to caps writing, I apologize but can assure you that my opinion is not panicky but factual. If the flight is a full load where can this poor dog fit on board? Passengers complain about leg room let alone such a big dog. Airmalta is duty bound to consider what can go wrong.
@Raymond Sammut
A dog can be very well trained but if pressurization had to effect his ears, the pain will not rest with anybody let alone a 'trained' dog.
Expressing one's opinion is not creating panic but awareness which I am sure that Airmalta is professional enough to consider
J. Mifsud (on 15/8/08)
What's wrong with you people. Why always trowing stones to Airmalta & PN. What if this girl was boarding a low cost airline? Will they let her on board? I think that Airmalta was fair.
Anthony A. Mifsud (on 15/8/08)
Cheers boys,
weldone Brian and mr. Cappello, Another demonstration that Air Malta cares for our customers.
viva l-ghasafar ta comb, I Hope that there's a few out there that recalls this frase. Long live our Flag Carrier.
Tony
S. Farrugia (on 15/8/08)
@Mary Pace, generalising is always bad, you're saying that if a man killed someone, than all men are killers ...

Well done to airmalta, but pls tell me this why do we have to wait for others to tell us what to do, do we need EU regulations to let a guiding dog travel with his owner on airplanes??
John Azzopaardi (on 15/8/08)
This reminds me of the story of a lady passenger on British Airways who objected sitting next to a coloured person on the flight. She was very vociferous about it. The cabin crew quickly resolved the issue...they turned to the coloured man and politely showed him to a seat in the club class section at the front of the aircraft. The passengers broke into a spontaneous applause. Perhaps Air Malta should emulate this example...and allay the 'fears and concerns' of all the passengers who are objecting to the dog being allowed to travel with Catia.
c gatt (on 15/8/08)
Mr Cutajar should stop worrying about all the things that can go wrong.
oh and PS STOP WRITING WITH THE CAPS LOCK ON, IN INTERNET ETIQUETTE TERMS ITS CONSIDERED SHOUTING!

PPS Good on Air Malta for reacting so fast, even on a holday. Ah! The wonders of the internet! News that creates a reaction and its own news stories in less then 12 hours
Joseph E Briffa (on 15/8/08)
Well done Air Malta...You see the advantage of becoming an EU member state! The Maltese are laid back because they have always been a colony and are used to being guided and led by somebody else, being the feudal lords, the Knights of St John, the British. We have been independent for only 40 odd-years as against a colony for 1000s of years.
Raymond Sammut (on 15/8/08)
@ Kenneth Cutajar

"A DOG CAN REACT BADLY FOR VARIOUS REASONS AND HE CAN BITE PASSENGERS AND WORST OF ALL CREATE PANIC ON BOARD."

This is not just a "dog". It's a trained Labrador. This animal will never hurt a fly throughout its short lifespan. Pretty much guaranteed. There is a far greater probability of being hurt by a human than by a trained and well looked after Labrador under any given circumstance.

And the Labrador can wait outside just like a big adult. This animal would take far less space than I would.

I think we need to be community minded and not panicky reactionists. There are people who are genuinely phobic of dogs. So Air Malta will have to take things into consideration when seating passengers during check-in procedures.
Charles J Buttigieg (on 15/8/08)

Well done Brian, well done Joe Cappello. Another demonstration that Air Malta really cares. Keep up the good work and we will guarantee our continued support. Long live our Flag Carrier.
mary Pace (on 15/8/08)
While I simpytise with Ms lima,i myself if I was traveling with the same plane as her ,I would'nt board the plane with a dog so near! because I'm terrified of dogs,as once I was bitten by one,!! by all means let her dog travel with her but not near any pasengers!!
C. Psaila (on 15/8/08)
Please...do not come up with the idea that dogs are good and they do not bite.
What will the passengers who suffer from dog phobia do?...suffer a disasterous trip.
Emanuel W. Zarb (on 15/8/08)
Well done AirMalta. Further comments are obsolete. Great!
Jason Scerri (on 15/8/08)
Well Done Air Malta!
Malvin Debono (on 15/8/08)
It's amazing how the comments stopped after the update! Airmalta came under fire precisely because it was adhering to procedures. Some directives such as this one are subject to local legislation. Well done Air Malta for thinking outside the box and recifying the situation.
Kenneth Cutajar (on 15/8/08)
iT IS NOT A MATTER OF WAKING UP OR RESPECT FOR DOGS ETC.. BUT ONE HAS TO LOOK AT THE WHOLE SCENARIO. WHEREAS MS LIMA IS RIGHT TO EXPECT HER DOG WITH HER ON BOARD, WHAT ABOUT THE SAFETY OF THE AIRCRAFT AND PASSENGERS ON BOARD? WITH A PRESSURISED CABIN AT 38,000 FT A DOG CAN REACT BADLY FOR VARIOUS REASONS AND HE CAN BITE PASSENGERS AND WORST OF ALL CREATE PANIC ON BOARD. NO SYMPATHY MUST EVER COMPROMISE SAFETY AND I BELIEVE THAT MS LIMA SHOULD BE GIVEN INDIVIDUAL ATTENTION AND THE DOG GIVEN BACK TO HER UPON DISEMBARKING FROM THE AIRCRAFT. SHE DOESN'T NEED HER DOG TO WALK TO THE TOILETS BUT A CREW MEMBER CAN ASSIST. WHERE WOULD THE DOG WAIT UNTIL SHE IS IN THE TOILET? IT DOES NOT FIT IN THERE
M.Debono (on 15/8/08)
Well done to Mr. Brian Bartolo ... for reacting immediately to the timesofmalta.com report/comment, notwithstanding, today being a public holiday. These blogs are creating a new reality in todays' communication and expression of "issues" with services, companies, and the general "feeling" of individuals concerned with what is being reported, etc.
Keep it up .. Mr. Timesofmalta.com!!:)
Karl Abela (on 15/8/08)
@ Timothy Pace Lupi:
Yes it had to be the EU for us to arrange such issues because our island is made up of people like you who keep blaming the authorities/government for every single thing that goes wrong. Its an addictive habit which diverts the attention from the real cause of the problem. The real cause of the problem is us Maltese. We hunt how and when we like, we dump sewage in the sea, we mistreat animals, we pollute the air with sound and noise then we just blame the government. How very convenient and how politically sad you are.

Instead of moaning, wouldnt it better to start a petition and divert as many people as you can to this blog and ask them to sign their support for this woman?
Paul A Attard (on 15/8/08)
I have always considered Air Malta, the National Airline, as a first class airline. Well done for reconsidering the decision and accommodating the sight impaired woman.
Paul A Attard (on 15/8/08)
I have always considered Air Malta, the National Airline, as a first class airline. Well done for reconsidering the decision and accommodating the sight impaired woman.
Stephen Galea (on 15/8/08)
Well done to Airmalta for allowing Catia and her guide dog to travel together - even despite the short notice.
Roy Perry (on 15/8/08)
On a point of information. The Malta Guide Dog Foundation has been in talks with Air Malta for more than 12 months and has supplied much material to enable them to finally agree to allow Catia to travel with her dog and also to review their policy. I am a Guide Dog Owner and have wanted to travel by Air Malta fover a period of three years.
Karl Abela (on 15/8/08)
@ Timothy Pace Lupi:
Yes it had to be the EU for us to arrange such issues because our island is made up of people like you who keep blaming the authorities/government for every single thing that goes wrong. Its an addictive habit which diverts the attention from the real cause of the problem. The real cause of the problem is us Maltese. We hunt how and when we like, we dump sewage in the sea, we mistreat animals, we pollute the air with sound and noise then we just blame the government. How very convenient and how politically sad you are.

Instead of moaning, wouldnt it better to start a petition and divert as many people as you can to this blog and ask them to sign their support for this woman?
Joe Savona (on 15/8/08)
I will be happy to pay for the seat adjacent to Catia, for Lee to travel with her, if Air Malta will reconsider.
Nigel Lawrence (on 15/8/08)
Yet ANOTHER case where Malta has failed to implement EU regulations. Will someone please remind me WHY we joined the union? We are certainly NOT in unison with the EU in many aspects. Another double cross from the PN.
V.Catania (on 15/8/08)
"Despite an EU regulation regarding the carriage of assistance animals travelling by air, which came into effect last month, Air Malta has still not put into place operational procedures permitting this"

What are you waiting for Air Malta?

This is crass insensitivity and puts Malta into shame!
s aquilina (on 15/8/08)
Hope Ms Lima and Lee will find Malta more pet-friendly than our national airline.
Denis Catania (on 15/8/08)
Air Malta you are a first class airline, please allow this young lady and her dog on the flight tommorrow. These are her eyes, should there be an emergency, she will need her companion. This is not just a dog, this is her eyes. you have 24 hrs, to make a very important and humane decision,Air Malta, please make us proud again, as you always did in the past. I have faith you will acomodate her. Especially on Sant Maria.
sabine grech (on 15/8/08)
all my respect to the host family !!! I hope Catia is going to "enjoy " her stay !! i would be interested in the name of the language school!!
Victoria Grech (on 15/8/08)
Well said Timothy. why do we never take anything seriously in this country?
Robert Galea (on 15/8/08)
I would deffinatly refer to a 30 year old as a WOMAN and not a girl..................!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TIMOTHY PACE-LUPI (on 15/8/08)
Truely a sad storry! But havent we all got some sort of dilema to face due to the Maltese Authorities lack of action and decipline with regards to respecting standard proceedures and international regulation. Illegal Hunting, parking on pavements, dumping raw sewage at sea, poor public transport services, air pollution, sound and light pollution amd animal rights! Does it always have to be EU directives and intervention from the EC to get our government to pull up its socks??
Berys Said (on 15/8/08)
At what age does a girl become a woman.......................
Marc Psaila Soler (on 15/8/08)
Ok , lets start playing our favourite sport - throwing abuse at Air Malta or anything Maltese for that matter. Well done Joseph Briffa - you win the gold medal.

On another note, whilst I understand the concerns of the persons directly involved in this case, one must understand that Air Malta might have never felt the need to implement such procedures as it was probably never faced with such a situation before. I am sure our national airline will do its best to implement these procedures very swiftly - as, after all, Air Malta has always done its best to accommodate all passengers, including persons with special needs.
J.M. Chapelle (on 15/8/08)
oim.
James P. (on 15/8/08)
I just love dogs!
JOSEPH E BRIFFA (on 15/8/08)
WHY HASN'T AIRMALTA PUT IN OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES YET TO COME IN LINE? WHAT IS IT WAITING FOR? AIRMALTA WAKE UP!

Poll

Was the budget good for Malta?

  • yes
  • no
  • don't know
  • don't care


View results

Fun Stuff


Play Sudoku