
Tuesday, 1st July 2008
Church bells are a danger to health
In recent letters, Ramon Casha from Qormi stated that he lives close to a church and Matthew Mifsud of Balzan made no mention of any distance, but only bewails the fact that a considerate parish priest has decided to halt bell ringing at night.
Last year, Anna Spiteri from Senglea (The Sunday Times) had complained about the loud quarter-hour bell chimes and, if memory serves me well, she stated they reached 125dBA. If correct, she was right to complain as that level of noise is damaging to the ear, and could cause initial acoustic trauma leading to partial or total loss of hearing. The maximum limit of noise, considered acceptably moderate, for outdoors is 75dBA, while indoors the limit should be no more than 45dBA. Most church bells in Malta are probably much louder, both indoors and outdoors.
In the past, some mediaeval bells needed as many as 24 men to ring one bell, so most were small. When, some centuries ago, the automatic bell ringing system was invented it eliminated manpower, and they could be set to ring in advance at prescribed times, so larger and larger bells were foundered.
With the advent of this mechanism, the "torture masters" of the time caught on to these new torture weapons and "acoustic torture" was born, whereby a victim could quickly be reduced to a jelly-like total compliance to his masters by being exposed to prolonged, or spasmodic loud ringing. Little did it matter to them that the inhabitants living around the belfry were also subjected to the same treatment!
The health risks from noise are manifold and can cause both mental and physical damage. To name a few! Mental: aggression, bad temper, lack of concentration, severe stress, depression, panic attacks, etc. Physical: tinnitus, migraine headaches, impaired hearing, high blood pressure, rapid heartbeat, interrupted sleep or even insomnia, agitation, constant tenseness, etc. A quick browse on the internet for noise pollution will yield more information.
In Malta, not all parish priests indulge in spurious bell ringing, but those that do cause untold damage to the health of their parishioners and give the Maltese Church an uncaring reputation.
Is this reputation warranted? In a way, yes, for, curiously enough, the Curia has given all parish priests virtual total autonomy over their parishes, so that each local population surrounding each church is completely at their mercy (except through recourse to the Curia). Unfortunately, the lesser educated and more bad-mannered among these parish priests get to indulge themselves in an excess of power and control over others, until they are ordered to stop!
Fortunately, the Church in Malta is realising that this may have become a bit of a problem, especially during village feasts with their total noise.
An Environment Commission was set up to look into the anarchic manufacture of fireworks on these Islands. For their report access www.maltadiocese.org/page.aspx?p=1374&l=1 (click on statement on pyrotechnics - January 8, 2008). Their conclusions do not consider the many complaints the public has voiced over the noise factor; but perhaps another Commission report could be initiated to deal specifically with the great discontent the population shows over the unnecessary noise pollution generated by the Church in Malta from both petards and bell ringing.
Writing to the newspapers to complain achieves very little as the long-desired changes need to be made by the Curia themselves from the very top, but it is always up to individual people to write to inform them of their views and experiences and so bring things to change for the better!






RSS
Comments
Today the use of bells has changed from one of use to musical beauty. Not all bells are modern hence their musical limitations however their role (albeit restricted because of change of culture) has been reduced. In this regard without meaning to offend anyone, may I appeal that most of us bell ringers are very aware that they may constitute discomfort to the people that cannot understand the ringing language being conveyed by the bells, hence the fact that the ringing session sounds so endless.
Well, if you decide to go and live smack opposite a traditional parish church which for centuries has prided itself with beautiful bells, well, what do you expect?????? I recall a silly man who did just that, bought a house just opposite the church and the first thing he did was to annoy us, the readers, with his complaints about the church bells disturbing him! I mean ... if you go and live at Luqa or Gudja, ... will you tell the government to close down MIA or transfer it to Comino?????
I was born, literally, and lived much of my life under the flight path of aeroplanes taking-off and landing over our heads - literally, I stress again! Day and night! And we never minded them!
And now, .... we don't even have time to listen to the bells! What a sorry state man has reached.
But it would be no use having one standard for developers, car stereos and other noise polluters and allow parish priests ringing their bells whenever thay please.
The priests should lead by example.
Giving out ipods to the faithful with a recording of church bells is far cheaper, easier and not as ridiculous as to expect people to uproot themselves and move farther - which if enough of them do, the Curia would soon declare it a new parish and build a new church - with bells - in their midst anyway!
the village feast or other important feasts such as Easter Sunday. ?
While reading your letter my stomach started turning upside down especially
when reading that church bells may cause the mental damage you mentioned.
A.Cortis, People like you are becoming (tat dwejjaq)for us Maltese.
The church bells have been ringing for hundreds of years and I never heard
of any mental case because of bell ringing.
The mental damage which you mentioned are more likely to be caused by people
like you.
My last comment goes to ALL parish priests in Malta.Keep ringing those bells as it
was done for hundred of years and to the Balzan Parish Priest
to start ringing again the church bells because the Balzan community is
very disappointed with your decision.
A.Cortis do not reply trying to explain to me about sound level and how it is meausered.
I can also suggest to you to use ear plugs
"So what, may I ask? You any better, then?"
Well may you ask!
Evidently there must be a slight case of language barrier. The point is, would a 'fervent catholic' blatantly disregard an order from the curia - as A Farrugia seemed to imply.
Of course, if you are one, you might know the answer to that one; not being 'any better' I wouldn't know. ;-)
So what, may I ask? You any better, then?
There is nothing lovilier than silence broken by church bells.
Bells in Malta are common, to me they remind me of my youth when i lived in Valletta and bring back fond memories. Leave these things alone and if anyone has a problem then move to somewhere where there is no noise ( Mr Gavin Attard, this is no insult, just a realistic proposal), which is close to impossible in any country let alone this tiny rock.
Mr Flynn - ignored. As is so easy to do in this technological age.
I too do not enjoy noise, especially the useless fireworks let off early in the morning, but to complain of bells ringing is truly a sad case of moaning just for the sake of it!
With all the noise pollution in this country is this really something we should be talking about? Busses, car stereos, building noise, P1 Power boats, Air rally, xalata every Monday, students at all hours of the night etc etc etc.......
"Never, not even if the Curia orders us to stop them. "
Evidently, you are a very fervent 'catholic'!
After all, they are the ones who are paying for the 'privilege'. ;-)
Drivers listening to loud music in their car is just as bad as the church bells. Get rid of them both...
ok seriously, chruch bell ringing should not be banned, but it should be regulated.
The fiugures above are failry accurate. Though it does not tell the whole story. At 80dB you can lsiten continously for up to 8 hours. Every 3dB you add to that, half the safe duration for listening time.
I have never heard a church clock chime so loud as to disturb one's sleep at night. During the day, with the normal noise level made by traffic and other sources, one can hardly take notice of the quarter hour strikes. Church bells have been pealing for centuries and at much earlier hours and for far longer periods than today and no one ever got deaf or lost much sleep over them. Maybe those complaining suffer from a sleep disorder and should have their condition checked out.
Perhaps Mr. Flynn should Protest himself?
Besides, what backs the noise levels stats quoted above?
It is rather sad to see ppl like yourself resorting to the "get out of our country" line. Try this. i am Maltese, the bells are a health hazard, as are the fireworks. So now what Farrugia? got a line for me?
Surely a deep faithed man, as you seem to be, does not require such paganisitc practices to show devotion to your invisible friend.