• email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Hospital waiting lists are a scandal - Dalli

Social Policy Minister John Dalli yesterday described the hospital waiting lists as "scandalous" saying it was unheard of that one had to wait up to five years for certain operations.

Focusing on e-health during his contribution to the debate in Parliament on the Central Registry Bill, Mr Dalli said that, where necessary, he was willing to consult with everyone. But decisions had to be taken. It was not on that one had to be put on a waiting list for an operation which would take only a few minutes. There had to be good, disciplined management putting patients first and providing them with the best possible service.

Mr Dalli said that the Bill should provide a leap in quality.

One could now develop electronic ID cards which would include information that could eliminate a lot of discomforts, like queuing up for certificates. It was useful for one and all if the country had a common database that would include holistic information on individuals and property. This legislation, the minister said, would open up new and better horizons.

The information to be available could be interesting for a lot of different uses. When analysing what information was to be included in the system, one had to consider what it was going to be used for.

Methods had to be established as to what information was to be accessible and by whom. One had to ensure that systems would have the necessary safeguards to avoid prying, prevent computer fraud and identity theft.

He stressed the importance of updating the information so that it would not become outdated.

He pointed out that a lot of progress has been registered in e-government and Malta was currently known as the most developed country in the sector. Through this system the public could fill applications and forms from the comfort of their own home.

The common database would be of vital importance to continue expanding e-government services.

One of the services to be expanded was that of e-health. This would include a whole database of the medical history of the people, not for prying purposes but so that it could be used in the health system. Through one's ID number, a doctor would know what tests one would have already sat for, the results and what needed to be done. Mr Dalli said that e-health was also needed for the development of primary care. The government acknowledged it was more comfortable for the people and more efficient for the country if this sector worked effectively and more efficiently.

Primary care services had to be expanded. Many matters which were not of an acute nature should no longer be treated in hospital. Health centres had to be well manned and equipped for patients to go closer to home, be served quicker rather than wait for hours at the Emergency Section. There were many factors to be considered in solving this problem and now that the migration had been carried out, one had to go into Mater Dei protocols, systems and staffing to ensure efficiency and the cost benefit of all that was being done.

Mr Dalli said the bottom line in a business plan for Mater Dei was patient satisfaction. He was amazed at the quality and capability of Maltese doctors and nurses. They were unequal so everyone should work together to see how these assets were exploited.

What Malta had was good and it was praised for it. Foreigners wanted to use Malta's health services and the government did not want to tell them it did not have enough resources because these were available.

He appealed for everyone's cooperation, including the opposition's. The sector, he said, should not be turned into a political ball. He should be criticised when he erred but the sector should not be sensationalised. One should not create unnecessary gripes. Malta could have the best possible health sector and it should be built with everyone's cooperation.

The country had been successful in the financial services because there was a receptive opposition which had understood the benefits for the country in setting it up. Although Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici had not been persuaded initially that the government did not have a hidden agenda, when he realised that there were none, both sides cooperated together for Malta to have the best possible legislation.

Mr Dalli promised that in such important sectors he would be seeking even the opposition's help and he hoped it would be given.

For a good primary health system, a flow of information on patients was required. It was important that GPs and health centres could download that patient's history to ensure that a patient did not suffer more harm than good.

It was important to have a planned and controlled structure and the Bill was setting up the medium which would make information availability possible.

A module was introduced for blood tests and this was currently being tested. Blood tests were digitised for results to be available to all those who were authorised to have them. Ambulance men would also be able to read one's history from the electronic ID.

Turning to the registration of property, Mr Dalli called for the development of systems which would lead to one knowing how property could be developed.

Before having a regulatory masterplan for the whole country, it was impossible to get to sustainable development. It was important to know where and what development could be undertaken.

It was only then that Mepa permits would be given within 12 weeks if developers' applications were in line. He said that in Libya, a development register showed what a parcel of land was intended for. If they acquired permits for different development underhandedly, that development could be demolished even years later. Development permits in Libya, he said, were issued within four weeks.

He said that there had to be Mepa policies which made sense and then insist that they were followed by everyone.

  • Google Bookmarks Del.icio.us Facebook Blogger YahooMyWeb Digg Reddit Stumbleupon
  • email article
  • print article
  • small text sizemedium text sizelarge text size
  • comment on this article

Comments

Oscar Cassar (on 3/6/08)
If Hon Dalli will get the bull from its horns as he did with the financial deficit of the country, we are to be reassured the waiting list will be history in a couple of weeks… Come on and let as put political arguments aside and work in the real interest of the country. There are problems in the civil service that must be addressed immediately if we really wish that the country does not see her best human resources going abroad after financing for free their education.
Ben grech (on 2/6/08)
@John I agree with you there. However the actual number of doctors, nurses, nursing aides etc is the real problem here. Instead of spending an almost 700 million euros on the actual building, they could have easily spent considerably less. Of course that would have meant better management of the project per say. Those funds could have easily been utilised to invest in increasing the wages and career prospects of local medical staff.
JOHN SCERRI (on 31/5/08)
Dear Ben : You know as much as I do that the most difficult task when upgrading is to convince the staff into to change to new procedures and work practices by means of training .
Some take it as a challenge and succeed but others resist until they are convinced that change is being done for thier own good.
This takes time - but there comes a moment when those who keep on resisting no matter what must realize that the place is not the right one for them - so they better find work elsewhere.
Mater Dei is not just the building and the equipment - it is also the staff who run it.
Ben Grech (on 31/5/08)
So Mater Dei's opening really didn t make much of a difference when it comes to the efficiency and effectiveness of our health sector. Its amazing how for years the government ignored calls by the medical unions and opposition for more investment in human resources. No one apparently had a right to criticise the government's efforst in the health sector after building such a modern state of the art hospital.
L. Grech (on 31/5/08)
What is different between the MLP and the PN is that MLP officials have to go in front of the school's headmaster (IL BORD TAL VIGILANZA) every time they say something that contrasts their main stream whereas the PN officials say what they have to say and are not threatened everytime they do so. After all, the Maltese citizens are going to benefit from this issue because it seems that there is the intention to tackle this huge problem!
Marcel Dingli (on 31/5/08)
About this database, yes, who will have access to the information ?? I or my own private doctor have no access to my personal files. I agree, this is Big Brother bossing around.
JOHN SCERRI (on 30/5/08)
After reading this article and going through some comments below I feel the duty to mention that there is a Maltese proverb which states 'Iddardarx l-ilma li trid tixrob minnhu'.

One day , when we least expect it, we or one of our relatives shall need to be assisted by medical staff : nurses,doctors,surgeons and ancillary staff in Mater dei hospital or any other health center.
One day, when they least expect it......also medical staff : nurses,doctors,surgeons and ancillary staff will themselves become patients in their own place of work.

Therefore it is EVERYONE'S responsability including those working in all health sectors to put aside every other interest and concentrate purely on how patients can be given the best possible quality health care in the shortest possible time.

Considering the thousands of surgical procedures carried out each year including Sundays and public holidays one cannot say all is wrong -
There are many workers whose job satisfaction is seeing a person walk out of hospital better than when he or she entered.

This is the attitude health care staff want but some need to be motivated into building it within themselves.

So all of us can give a hand.


R.Gauci (on 30/5/08)
Another nice coloured baloon bursted up!! Bongu Malta
mario gauci (on 30/5/08)
Well done Minister Dalli. It is now Minister Mifsud Bonnici's turn to speak out about the appalling waiting list in our courts. Let us get Malta up to EU standard. Minister Dalli is a very successful man both as a Minister and as a bussiness man, while Minister Mifsud Bonnici has proved he has won the prime minister's confidence and he has youth on his side. I hope this is the new way politics is going to be seen to be done. I for one am in favour. Let us all stop complaing and give Ministers like these the backing they deserve. Good luck gentleman.
eric saliba (on 30/5/08)
come on all you guys !! the only problem we have in malta is the labour party leadership contest !! what waiting lists? what higher cost of living? what higher oil prices?
haven't read about these anywhere. just open the papers/television and all we are told is how much back stabbing and bickering there is within the labour party.
i wonder how editors will be able to fill their pages after june 5th when everything else is running so smoothly.
but then we got the govt that we deserve didn't we ??
Joe Galea (on 30/5/08)
Where are all the PN apologists? Are you so shocked with this revelation? Did you realise that MLP have been saying this for the last 5 years?
Can John Dalli who doesn't understand anything about medical care tell us his big plan to make the Health System especially Mater Dei much more efficient? Oh by the way he wants to seek also the MLP advice on this!! So MLP is not that crap as the know-it-all venom spitting PN apologists depict every day!!!
A Bonnici (on 30/5/08)
I agree with K Caruana. I am a Health Care worker...will not tell if i am a doctor or nurse. From doctors' side only consultants got a pay rise not house officers or senior house officers...who work average 80 hours a week for a ridiculous pay. And then they talk about brain drain. From the nurses side...they also have horrible conditions and long hours and are not treated well by the administration. The staff in Mater Dei is getting squeezed day after day so that the service continues to run. Believe me in a few years time there will be no doctors or nurses to take care of our patients in Malta...and this only thanks to the mismanagement in the health sector. Human conditions..normal working hours and a good pay like abroad is the solution to keep the staff
Marco Spiteri (on 30/5/08)
Have the nationalist bloggers nothing to say.

Weren't dalli and deguara part of the same pn governments over the last years..... Dik vizjoni......dik tmexxija...... what has gonzi to say
M Borg (on 30/5/08)
Sure a scandal! Waiting lists can be reduced to the minimum and we can use our Mater Dei to increase revenues as well. What shall be done is that hospital staff will work on 24hr basis on operations/test etc, and not only half-days all year round!! This way, a 4 year waiting list can be done in less than a year. When we reach the objective/goal that we have no waiting lists at all, then the next step will be that we start advertising our services in both mainland Europe and also our other African nations. Private patients will then come here for medical services and the charges will surely help our financial deficit!
Joe Galea (on 30/5/08)
Oh what a revelation? John the oracle has spoken!!!
philip pace (on 30/5/08)
For Mr.Dalli to state that, it means that the MLP were right after all. So the score is in favour of the MLP.
In December, I had a guest staying with me and she needed the pills from Mater Dei and after she got the pills, I asked if there was any water for her to swallow the pills but there was no water dispenser around and the smug and too relaxed receptionist told her to use the water tap to swallow the pills. Can you see that Mr.Dalli?
I wrote about it and two correspondents tried to ridicule me with their own partisan beliefs. They failed.
Now regarding the database, Mr.Dalli is treading on dangerous grounds here as it smells like 'Big Brother'.
I simply ask him, ' who shall have the access to the personal database?'.
How can I have peace of mind when my personal and confidential information can be known by a click on the computor?
You have to thread very carefully here, Mr.Dalli as that is a minefield.
Probably other nations tried this but what about my protection towards my personal and confidential information?
This a bureaucratic dictatorship.
I doubt if it would work!
K Caruana (on 30/5/08)
A small correction Mr Sultana - consultants were given a hefty pay rise - the doctors who would see you at A&E are mostly made up of house officers and senior house officers whose pay is worse than the average maid's - even after the new MAM agreement! If you think these doctors make good money look at the hours they work to see where they get it from.
Resources by the way Dr Dalli are not sufficient in the Human Resources Sector and should be getting worse with every passing day when more and more junior doctors are fleeing the island in search of better working hours, better pay and more respect at the workplace.
It's time to invest in the worker, not stones, mortar and equipment.
w. sammut (on 30/5/08)
Now, now, what's wrong in Dalli pointing out one hopeless situation brought about by mismanagement on the part of his government! Just one of... So Deguara, and rightly so, took offence. But the nationalists say nothing. All is hush . On the other hand, when any two members of the Labour Party, do not agree on something, and say so, this is exploited and referred to as bickering, division, etc etc within the party, by the nationalists, and we hear about it for a very long time.

Marco Spiteri (on 30/5/08)
I really can't believe my ears. Is this John dalli of Gonzi PN. History reeats itself. Remeber the "Hofra Hrafa". Oh by the way hasn't the Gonzi Administration just finished dismantling the primary health service... and now they are saying that these are a major requirement. That is really a self imposed U TURN.

I ask what is next.........fees.....aren't we paying more than enough taxes some even extracted from our pockets by the same minister when he was resonsible for finance.

State of the art hospital......lousy service.........and oh God forbid what it would have been like had laobour not been elected in 1996 and enlarged the hospital from 450 beds to 900 beds. Either you would have been thrown out after an operation or else the queues would have become much worse or else we would have had to retain two hospitals and what an expense.

This reminds me of education......state of the art schools........disastrous student results.......but on the other hand we have old church schools with good student results.

Malta government = Tlellix....Tghasar u ma ssibx xejn.
Kevin Zammit (on 29/5/08)
"One could now develop electronic ID cards which would include information that could eliminate a lot of discomforts, like queuing up for certificates. It was useful for one and all if the country had a common database that would include holistic information on INDIVIDUALS AND PROPERTY. "

hahahhahahahahah!!!!!!!!

As a pure maltese bred I can only say to this "Mr. Dalli, is your second name Fidele"?

Give me a break man! please!?! so you give us all this big story of heroic deeds to hide what you had planning since the VAT days? i.e. getting to know who owns what and how much.

Hey ... I'm fine with that except that we all know how these things turn out ... politics is on the side of those that bankroll an election not the middle class that drives the economy.
James Sultana (on 29/5/08)
GOOD MORNING DEAR JOHN !!!! WELCOME BACK FROM HIBERNATION !!!!

Where were you during the past years ? I bet that we will soon be told that the reason for this waiting list is because way back in 1996 Alfred Sant had decided to enlarge the hospital !! WE (not the government) spent millions on this hospital which may be state of the art, but which is not big enough, which cost way too much more than it should have cost .... and which at the end of the day is still manned, managed and directed by the same people.

Just before the election (what a co-incidence !!!) the medical professionalists were given a very hefty pay rise with the excuse that this would now encourage them to work at Mater Dei rather than "suggest" to the patients that if they want to get quicker treatment they should go to private hospitals .... the result ????

Maybe know Mr. Dalli will come out in the budget to tell us that the free-health system is not sustainable and this is why there are large waiting lists !!
Charles DeMicoli (on 29/5/08)
Bravo to Minister John Dalli for putting aside partisanship and being fortright and calling a spade a spade. I do hope the Opposition heeds his advice for the benefit of all.
ALBERT FENECH (on 29/5/08)
Well done Minister Mr. John Dalli for having the guts and honesty to admit there is a frightful situation regarding lengthy hospital waiting lists. When the MLP claimed the same during the electoral period, they were accused of spreading malicious lies and "mud-slinging". How the ball has changed from one foot to the other! Above all, this should not be a "party" matter, but a national priority as it affects all of us.
john mahoney (on 29/5/08)
A few days before Easter my wife drove me to Mater Dei Emergency as I was under a colic attack .We got there at 5.00pm ,after six hours of waiting we were told we had to wait for approx three more hours to be seen too. Everyone could see I was in absolute pain could not even talk with pain. At last my family took me to a private hospital where I was operated on . It cost me over 1000 euros. Well Mr Dalli who is going to refund me with the cost of the operation ? There were over eight security officers doing nothing , the customer care girl kept disappearing and there was no one around to check the real emergency cases. WHAT A SHAME.....
Joseph Galea (on 29/5/08)
Glad to see that the Minister considers the waiting lists at the hospital to be a scandal.

E-health processes should make obtaining appointments and services smoother and easier, provided one gets everybody's cooperation. For example, why cannot an appointment for a particular screening procedure be given there and then rather than be told that "you will receive the appointment in the mail - but be prepared to wait for about two years - and the result would be given some six months later." Two and a half years!!! If indeed there was something developing, it might be too late to do anything about it when the result is received. The only other alternative is to have the procedure done privately and pay up.

In other countries where I have lived such procedures, when ordered by the GP, were performed within a maximum of four weeks! There is no reason why Malta cannot approach this standard.
M. Brincat (on 29/5/08)
A scandal eh? That's what MLP has been saying over and over again for the last 5 years!

And now what? We fall from the stars?

Poll

Was the budget good for Malta?

  • yes
  • no
  • don't know
  • don't care


View results

Fun Stuff


Play Sudoku