For members of the medical profession
On discussing abortion, it is imperative to highlight that the provisions on abortion in our Criminal Code fall under Title VIII which speaks "Of Crimes Against the Person".
This leads us to correctly conclude that for all criminal law intents and purposes the unborn child is since conception considered a person and the procured miscarriage (=abortion) of the unborn child at any stage since conception is a crime.
To safeguard the life of the unborn person, section 243 reads: "Any physician, surgeon, obstetrician, or apothecary, who shall have knowingly prescribed or administered the means whereby the miscarriage is procured, shall, on conviction, be liable to imprisonment for a term from 18 months to four years, and to perpetual interdiction from the exercise of his profession".
In this section the law requires the specific intention: "knowingly". Normally, the way the perpetrator behaves in committing this crime points clearly to his intention. Besides, the means themselves used in carrying it out highlight one's intention. An English saying runs: "Where there is a will, there is a way", so the way manifests the intention.
The law here specifies "prescribed or administered". Prescription is normally a written document but it can be by word of mouth. A written prescription can easily be produced as evidence in court. A verbal prescription, of course, needs witnesses.
The law refers to "the means whereby the miscarriage is procured". What are these means? Here we have to go to section 241 (1) which states: "Whosoever, by any food, drink, medicine, or by violence, or by any other means whatsoever, shall cause the miscarriage of any woman with child, whether the woman be consenting or not, on conviction, be liable to imprisonment for a term from 18 months to three years".
So this is an all-inclusive clause regarding the means used: any means whatsoever, including pills.
If the mother dies as a consequence of the use of these means section 242 comes into play: "If the means used shall cause the death of the woman, or shall cause a serious injury to her person, whether the miscarriage has taken place of not, the offender shall, on conviction, be liable to the punishment applicable to wilful homicide or wilful bodily harm, diminished by one to three degrees".
Our law safeguarding the unborn has to be enforced in all circumstances. The entrenchment in the Constitution of the above provisions will surely be a step in the right direction. We are living in the 21st century where the whistleblower is hovering over our islands as well. Also the unborn need whistleblowers!
For the benefit of the unborn, a new provision which directly prohibits anyone on these islands from inciting or encouraging people to commit abortion anywhere should be introduced.
7 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Gerry Cowie
May 9th 2008, 19:24
Maria Fersti wishes to know who goes to jail if she is refused an abortion and dies.
What kind of a question is that? Since when has it been a crime for somebody to refuse to carry out an abortion? What would you say to a doctor who believes in the sanctity of human life? "Thou Shalt Kill - or go to jail?" Just as people may argue that a woman is free to have an abortion, there is nothing to force somebody who believes in the sanctitiy of human life to go against their own fundemental beliefs!
Joe Tabone-Adami
May 9th 2008, 15:27
Abortion, dear Ms Fersti, consists in voluntarily killing an innocent human being. Any serious comment should bear that in mind, please!
V Farrugia
May 9th 2008, 15:18
Mary Cassar states that no women have died in Malta in the case of maternal complications like ectopic pregnancies. What happens in that case? Is the baby aborted or induced prematurely?
Maria Ferstl
May 9th 2008, 13:06
The idea of abortion does scare me, but what definitely scares me much more is the idea that there is a country where in case of a serious illness I might be refused any medication that could "cause the miscarriage of any woman with child" and where in case of rape I would be forced by law to give birth to a being I could only hate.
Mary Cassar
May 9th 2008, 12:47
Ms. Ferstl implies that women are dying from abortion in Malta. For your information, your argument is pointless as no women has ever died in Malta because of a medical problem like for example, with ectopic pregnancies. Please try and be constructive in your suggestions Ms. Ferstl. Being alarmist in an attempt to create anxiety works when the point one makes is remotely realistic. In your case, you are simply being deceitful as this is not a problem in Malta due to the double effect principle that is practiced successfully.
Samuel Debono
May 9th 2008, 12:01
The female body can carry an unborn child believe it or not Ms. Ferstl. So unless complications arise the woman shouldn't die. If complications arise and surgical interventions are necessary it is usually the mother's choice if she or her child are given first priority - if the child dies that is not an abortion, and if the mother dies it is not due to any physician, surgeon, obstetrician or apothecary's fault but due to the complication - as can happen in all medical surgeries - are you saying that if during any surgery the patient dies it is the surgeon's fault and he/she should go to jail? Please do clarify your statement.
Maria Ferstl
May 9th 2008, 11:19
And if the woman dies because she is refused abortion, who goes to jail and for how long?